The biggest debt-collection arbitration outfit in America wasn't on Wall Street. It was at 6465 Wayzata Boulevard, St. Louis Park, and most Minnesotans never heard of it.

It was the National Arbitration Forum. When Minnesota's Attorney General sued it in 2009, the complaint called it "the nation's largest provider of consumer debt collection arbitrations" and listed the customers: "MBNA/Bank of America, JP MorganChase, Citigroup, Discover Card, Deutsche Financial, and American Express, among others." The Forum said it had been appointed the arbitrator in "hundreds of millions of contracts." In 2006 alone, the complaint said, it processed 214,000 consumer debt-collection claims. A congressional subcommittee's staff said it flat in July 2009: "Almost all of these mass debt collection arbitrations are conducted by the National Arbitration Forum."

Now the Minnesota number. The Forum's own records, as the House staff reported them, show 14,408 Forum arbitrations in Minnesota. Consumers filed 79. That's 0.5 percent. They called it "consumer arbitration", and consumers didn't use it. It happened to them.

The Attorney General's office later wrote that consumers who didn't know they'd agreed to arbitrate "didn't believe they were obligated to respond to an arbitration notice from an office in Minnesota." For Minnesotans, the office was down the road.

Who owned the referee?

Everything in this section comes from the complaint Attorney General Lori Swanson filed in Hennepin County District Court on July 14, 2009, court file 27-CV-09-18550. These are allegations. The case ended in a consent judgment the parties signed three days later, and that judgment says it "shall not be construed as an admission of wrongdoing or liability" by the Forum.

The complaint alleged that in 2006 and 2007 a family of New York hedge funds called Accretive set up private equity funds under the name "Agora", which, the complaint helpfully points out, means "Forum" in Greek. Subtle. Those funds "invested $42 million in the National Arbitration Forum and obtained governance rights in it." The deal closed in June 2007 and bought 40 percent of Forthright, one of three companies the complaint says "effectively operate as one" Forum.

Meanwhile three of the country's largest collection law firms merged into one, Mann Bracken, LLP. Then, the complaint says, Accretive "formed and funded (partly using federal money from the U.S. Small Business Administration) a debt collection agency called Axiant, LLC, which acquired the assets and collections operations of Mann Bracken." Per the complaint, Axiant has said the Accretive group owns 68.7 percent of it.

So who filed the Forum's cases? In 2006, the complaint says, Mann Bracken and Wolpoff & Abramson "filed over 125,000, or 58 percent," of the Forum's 214,000 consumer collection claims. Follow the State's chart and one investment group lands on both sides of the table: a stake in the referee, and control of the collection company that took over the operations of Mann Bracken, the firm whose predecessors had filed most of the Forum's 2006 cases.

All the while, the Forum told the public, on its website and elsewhere, "The FORUM is independent and neutral. It is not affiliated with any party." And: "The FORUM receives no funds from any source, other than fees paid for dispute resolution services." Hold that up next to the $42 million.

You'll hear it said the credit card companies set the Forum up. The record I have doesn't say who founded it. What it says is more specific, and worse. The banks wrote the Forum into the fine print. Then, the State alleged, money tied to some of the biggest collection firms bought into the referee.

In their own words

The complaint quotes the August 2006 proposal Accretive made to the Forum. Investor pitches are usually dull. This one isn't:

"In established markets, such as credit card, NAF exploits clause placements and becomes the preferred collections tactic where speed and cost are critical considerations. Arbitration should capture at least 50% of the volume currently placed in litigation"

And the big finish:

"Arbitration expands to become a comprehensive, alternative legal system."

"[P]referred collections tactic". That's what the money thought a neutral referee was for. Accretive told the Forum it could "help NAF become a billion-dollar company." Not a fairer one. A billion-dollar one.

Then there's the Forum's own sales material. The complaint quotes a PowerPoint shown to a financial services company, with a table titled "Reactions to Arbitration As Told By Customer Service Representatives":

"The customer does not know what to expect from Arbitration and is more willing to pay"

"They [customers] ask you to explain what Arbitration is then basically hand you the money"

"You have all the leverage and the customer really has little choice but to take care of this account"

I had to read that twice. A company selling itself as a neutral judge was pitching lenders on how well its process rattled borrowers into paying.

It gets better. The complaint says the Forum employed "a Vice President of Clause Placement", with clause-placement executives "partially compensated on a commission basis" for getting companies to write Forum clauses into their customer agreements. A vice president. Of clause placement. Picture a courthouse with a commissioned sales staff. Swanson's phrase for it, testifying to Congress that July, was "backroom hustling".

The numbers, and the Forum's answer

Most of what the public knew about the Forum's results came from California. As of 2007 it was, in Public Citizen's words, "the only state in the country that requires arbitration providers to publicly disclose any information at all". Public Citizen ran the Forum's California disclosures for The Arbitration Trap in September 2007. Between January 1, 2003 and March 31, 2007, the Forum handled 34,000 California consumer arbitrations. Consumers brought 118. "In the more than 19,000 cases in which an NAF-appointed arbitrator was involved, 94 percent of decisions were for business." Consumers won 4 percent; the report says the records didn't list a winner in the rest. And "a small, busy cadre of 28 arbitrators handled nearly 9 out of every 10 NAF cases", ruling for business 95 percent of the time. The busiest one signed 68 decisions in a single day, awarding the creditors "every penny" of the nearly $1 million they demanded. That's not a judge. That's a stamp.

The House staff dug deeper, and this one stuck with me. It pulled 159 California claim files, all filed by the same creditor at about the same time. "Two arbitrators dismissed all of the 58 claims that were assigned to them. The third arbitrator issued awards to the creditor in every one of the claims assigned to him." The staff couldn't find a difference in the files that justified it. It also found that 70 percent of the claims it reviewed should have been dismissed under the Forum's own Rule 6, because notice went out late. Its own rule. And in Maine, "one arbitrator who was actually following the NAF's rules, and dismissing cases that were deficient, found himself without any subsequent case assignments." The staff says the Forum then adopted a written rule that stopped sending him Maine cases, "purportedly because he was not a Maine attorney." Follow the rules, lose the work. Swanson's office separately reported that arbitrators and employees told it arbitrators who ruled against the corporation were "deselected".

Now the Forum's side, and some of it lands. Its chief operating officer told the same subcommittee "the results in court are the same as the results in arbitration." Professor Christopher Drahozal testified that in his court samples, in what he called preliminary findings, "the creditors won 99.7 percent of the cases," and that "96 percent to 98 percent of these cases in court were resolved by default judgments in favor of the creditor. Basically, the consumers just didn't show up." His warning: "You can't just look at numbers in one setting and conclude that means a process is biased or unbiased." The subcommittee's ranking member said "the best evidence available would indicate that those problems are worse in litigation than in arbitration." Even the majority staff conceded "the vast majority of consumers default and do not appear when claims are brought against them in courts," and noted that the files it examined were decided before the Forum restructured.

So I'll concede it. The 94 percent, standing alone, proves less than it sounds like. Collection cases are lopsided everywhere, because most people never show up. The scandal is what defaults don't explain: matching files that won or lost by arbitrator, a rule-follower who stopped getting cases, and, the State alleged, a referee whose investors were tied to the firms that had filed most of its cases while it told the public it wasn't affiliated with anybody. Courts have defaults too. Courts don't let the collection side's backers buy a stake in the courthouse.

Ten days in July

On July 14, 2009, the State sued. On July 17, the Forum and the State signed a consent judgment. Three days. Its stated purpose was "to require the complete divestiture by the NAF Entities of any business related to the arbitration of consumer disputes." Paragraph 3 is where it bit:

"On or after July 24, 2009, no NAF Entity shall: a. Accept any fee for processing any new Consumer Arbitration. b. Administer or process any new Consumer Arbitration. c. In any manner participate in any new Consumer Arbitration. . . ."

Ten days from complaint to cutoff. No admission of anything. Just out.

The other big provider left too. At the House hearing on July 22, the American Arbitration Association's witness said, "we do not currently handle nor would we receive these cases at least until some standards are established that are satisfactory." The AAA's posted notice said it had "determined not to accept new consumer debt collection arbitration filings as described below effective immediately", covering company-filed credit card, telecom and consumer-finance cases, and it cited, "among other things, a high rate of non-participation by the consumers." A 2011 version of the notice said the moratorium "remains in effect."

The Forum's chief operating officer saw where it would go: "The logical conclusion of this decision is that the consumer cases will all now be brought in court."

In September, in the piece on mass arbitration, I wrote that the companies that force you into arbitration run to court the minute they want to collect. Still true. Until 2009 it ran the other way. Arbitration was the collection tool, and Minnesota took it away. The forum was never the point. Collecting was, and the industry walked through whichever door was open.

The clauses moved too. The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's 2015 arbitration study, describing research by Rutledge and Drahozal, reports that between 2009 and 2010 "the percentage of credit card loans subject to arbitration clauses declined from 95.1% to only 48.0%." Rutledge and Drahozal credited two events: the Forum leaving consumer arbitration after Minnesota's lawsuit, and a separate antitrust settlement in which four large card issuers agreed to drop their clauses for three and a half years. Two events. One of them was filed in Hennepin County.

Washington wrote it down. Then Congress threw it out.

That study was the one Dodd-Frank ordered. On July 19, 2017, the Bureau published a rule meant to stop covered companies from using an arbitration clause "to bar the consumer from filing or participating in a class action". It was set to take effect September 18, 2017, and to apply to agreements made on or after March 19, 2018.

The Federal Register gives Minnesota the credit, in the Bureau's words: "[U]ntil it was effectively shut down by the Minnesota Attorney General, the National Arbitration Forum (NAF) was the predominant administrator for certain types of arbitrations." California got a nod too: "the California law requiring the reporting of arbitration statistics led to the investigations of arbitral administrators by city and State regulators, caused NAF to stop administering consumer arbitrations".

Then Congress voted to disapprove it. The House went first, on July 25, 2017, 231 to 190. Minnesota's eight House members split three for, five against: Emmer, Lewis and Paulsen voted aye; Ellison, McCollum, Nolan, Peterson and Walz voted no. The Senate took it up on October 24, 2017. The official tally reads "Joint Resolution Passed (50-50, Vice President voted Yea)". Both Minnesota senators, Franken and Klobuchar, voted no. Public Law 115-74, approved November 1, 2017, says the rule "shall have no force or effect."

A 50–50 tie. That's how close the federal answer to St. Louis Park came.

Congress knows how to say no. Since Dodd-Frank, no residential mortgage loan may include "terms which require arbitration or any other nonjudicial procedure". The Military Lending Act makes an agreement "to arbitrate any dispute involving the extension of consumer credit" unenforceable against covered service members and their dependents. And on March 3, 2022, after a 335–97 House vote, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act became law. Everybody else's credit card? The one federal rule that reached the clause got voided on a tie.

And Minnesota?

This is the part that bugs me. Minnesota did the hard thing in 2009 with a lawsuit. It never wrote the win into law.

In 2010 the Legislature adopted a Uniform Arbitration Act, 2010 Minn. Laws ch. 264, on votes of 133–0 and 128–0 in the House and 60–3 in the Senate. That's a general arbitration statute, not a consumer protection. In 2018, HF 3480 proposed that arbitration under a consumer-reporting-agency contract "must be venued in the county of this state where the consumer resides." It got a second reading on March 26, 2018, and never reached a floor vote.

In 2019 the Legislature required assisted-living contracts to disclose any arbitration clause clearly and conspicuously, and in 2025 it wrote a real rule, for one group: an assisted-living facility "must not require any resident or the resident's representative to sign an agreement for binding arbitration as a condition of admission to, or as a requirement to continue to receive care at, the facility." That's Minn. Stat. § 144G.51(c). Good rule. It covers an assisted-living apartment, not a credit card.

This year, SF 4289 and its House companion, HF 4219, went at the clause directly. The Senate Judiciary and Public Safety Committee reported it "To pass" on April 7, 2026, and re-referred it to Commerce and Consumer Protection. It never came out. The Legislature adjourned for the biennium on May 18, 2026, and the bill died there; it would have to be introduced again in 2027.

The Attorney General needed ten days. Seventeen years on, Minnesota has not enacted a general consumer-arbitration law.

What we can do

Bring the bill back in 2027, pass it, and finish it. SF 4289's core sentence is short: "A person must not require a consumer to enter into an arbitration agreement before or during the sale of a good or service." After the sale, a business could still offer arbitration, but only if "the agreement to arbitrate is clear and conspicuous and separate from other general terms related to the sale of the good or service." The bill says an agreement that breaks that rule, and any waiver of it, "are contrary to public policy and are void and unenforceable". What it leaves out is reporting. That's a miss. California requires an arbitration company to "collect, publish at least quarterly, and make available to the public" a cumulative report on every consumer arbitration in the preceding five years. Minnesota hosted the Forum, and it took California's law to expose it. We should have our own. Any state rule on arbitration has to clear the Federal Arbitration Act, and I covered that fight in the piece on the jury you lost. That's a reason to draft carefully. It's no reason to let the bill die in committee again.

Use the power the 2009 case proved. The State didn't need a new statute to shut down the Forum. It sued under the consumer-fraud, deceptive-trade-practices and false-advertising laws already on the books, read the sales deck, followed the ownership chart in a year-long investigation, and had the Forum out of consumer arbitration ten days after it filed. Any referee that lives on repeat corporate filers deserves the same look at who owns it and who's paying it. Minnesota already knows how.

And keep pulling the levers a state still has. Transparency, conflict rules for arbitrators, procurement, and the both-ways game on collections are all in the September agenda. Start with transparency.

None of this was hidden. It's in a Hennepin County court file, a congressional hearing record and the Federal Register. The win Minnesota got was a consent judgment the Forum signed three days after it was sued. That judgment names the Forum's three companies. The next outfit isn't in it. Minnesota beat the referee once. It never changed the rules of the game.

First the facts. Then the fix.


Sources

The lawsuit: Complaint, State of Minnesota by its Attorney General, Lori Swanson v. National Arbitration Forum, Inc., National Arbitration Forum, LLC, and Dispute Management Services, LLC, d/b/a Forthright, Hennepin County District Court, Fourth Judicial District (dated and stamped July 14, 2009), ¶¶ 2, 3, 7–9, 13, 14, 16, 18, 21–24, 33, 34, 52, 74, 80, 92, 96, 97, from the Attorney General's posted PDF (Internet Archive capture of ag.state.mn.us, June 16, 2012) and the National Consumer Law Center's mirror. Consent Judgment, Court File No. 27-CV-09-18550 (signed by the parties July 17, 2009), recitals and ¶¶ 1–3; Attorney General's letter to the American Arbitration Association, July 19, 2009; both from the Attorney General's press packet as posted by Public Citizen (Internet Archive capture). The complaint pleaded Minn. Stat. §§ 325F.69, subd. 1; 325D.44, subd. 1; and 325F.67.

The hearing: Arbitration or Arbitrary: The Misuse of Mandatory Arbitration to Collect Consumer Debts, Hearing before the Subcommittee on Domestic Policy of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, 111th Cong., Serial No. 111-125 (July 22, 2009), govinfo.gov, including the majority staff report "Arbitration Abuse: an Examination of Claims Files of the National Arbitration Forum" (Hearing Record pp. 14–18 and n.8) and the testimony of the Attorney General, the Forum's chief operating officer, the American Arbitration Association, and Professor Christopher R. Drahozal.

California data: Public Citizen, The Arbitration Trap: How Credit Card Companies Ensnare Consumers (September 2007), pp. 1–4 and 13, analyzing the Forum's disclosures under Cal. Code Civ. Proc. § 1281.96. Current text of § 1281.96(a) from leginfo.legislature.ca.gov (Internet Archive capture, May 27, 2026).

American Arbitration Association, "Notice on Consumer Debt Collection Arbitrations," adr.org (Internet Archive captures of August 22, 2009 and December 4, 2011).

Federal: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Arbitration Study: Report to Congress, pursuant to Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act § 1028(a) (March 2015), Section 2, p. 5. Arbitration Agreements, 82 Fed. Reg. 33210 (July 19, 2017), at 33210, 33252 and 33313. Pub. L. 115-74, 131 Stat. 1243 (Nov. 1, 2017). House Roll Call 412 (July 25, 2017) and Roll Call 33 (Feb. 7, 2022), clerk.house.gov. Senate Roll Call Vote 249, 115th Cong., 1st Sess. (Oct. 24, 2017), senate.gov (Internet Archive capture). Pub. L. 117-90, 136 Stat. 26 (Mar. 3, 2022). 15 U.S.C. § 1639c(e)(1) and 10 U.S.C. § 987(e)(3), (f)(4), Cornell Legal Information Institute.

Minnesota: revisor.mn.gov bill status and text for HF 1692/SF 891 (2009–2010; 2010 Minn. Laws ch. 264), HF 3480 (2018), and SF 4289/HF 4219 (2026); Minn. Stat. § 144G.51 and chapter 13C, 2026 edition; 2019 Minn. Laws ch. 60, art. 1, § 31, and 2025 Minn. Laws ch. 38, art. 2, § 21. Minnesota Legislative Reference Library, session dates for the 94th Legislature (lrl.mn.gov), and the Legislature's FAQ on when a bill dies (leg.mn.gov). All retrieved November 6, 2026.

What I could not establish. The only available copy of the consent judgment carries the parties' July 17, 2009 signatures but not the date the court entered it. The AAA's notice is undated on its face; the earliest capture is August 22, 2009. No record I found states when the Forum was founded or by whom. The ownership, funding and filing figures are the Attorney General's allegations, which the Forum never admitted. The 95.1 and 48.0 percent figures measure the share of credit card loans under arbitration clauses, not the share of issuers (which the same research put at 17.4 percent falling to 15.0), and the research the CFPB describes attributes the drop to two events, not one. The Revisor's records show no general consumer-arbitration law enacted in Minnesota since 2009; a bill-by-bill search of every session was not possible, so a bill introduced and never heard could be missing from the list above. Whether SF 4289 as written would survive a Federal Arbitration Act challenge is a legal question this piece doesn't answer. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.

Related research

Chosen by shared subject and shared statute, not by date.

Minnesota by the Numbers

Corporations Wrote 'You Must Fight Us One at a Time.' Then Lawyers Filed 280,000 Cases at Once — and the Companies Begged for a Class Action.

The same clause that locks you out of court can be turned into a weapon against the companies that wrote it. Mass arbitration, the 2022 sexual-harassment…

Minnesota by the Numbers

A Bank Admitted in Writing That My Account Was Drained by a Forged Check. Then It Sent Me to a Private Arbitrator — Who Turned Out to Work for the Other Side.

Forced arbitration's cruelest feature isn't that you usually lose. It's that it's secret. No public record, no precedent, no pattern exposed — so the same fraud…

Minnesota by the Numbers

Lip Service: Since 1851, a Minnesota Lawsuit Can Start Without a Court. Since 1990, the Statute Says a Creditor Can Garnish on One. Here's 175 Years of the Record, and What We Can Do About It.

Minnesota calls itself progressive. It also lets a debt suit start without a court filing, lets a creditor garnish on that unfiled suit 45 days later, keeps an…

← PreviousThe debt buyers98 of 114 in Minnesota by the NumbersNext →The lawsuit that was never filed

All of Minnesota by the Numbers →  •  The Dashboard →  •  The Receipts: every source →  •  The Platform →

Get the next one

New sourced research on Minnesota law, and the deadlines that matter before November 3. Every claim carries its source.

Subscribe Vote 2026: every deadline →

Discussion

Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.