Updated November 7, 2026: the court decisions and filings this piece describes are now named and cited in the text and Sources, and the piece notes that Minnesota's Attorney General intervened in the 1978 case.
Minnesota likes to call itself the progressive state. Here's a test.
In Minnesota, a debt collector can sue you without filing a thing in court. If you don't answer it, or the notice that follows, the collector can send a garnishment summons to your employer 45 days after you were served. The statute says it outright: "No filing of a pleading or other documents by the creditor is required to issue a garnishment summons under this clause". Texas won't let a credit card company near your paycheck at all. Neither will Pennsylvania or South Carolina. Minnesota will, on a lawsuit the court has never heard of.
None of that was an accident, and none of it's new. It's all in session laws and court rules nobody reads. Here's the whole run.
1851: the lawsuit that starts at your front door
The rule is older than the state. Minnesota's territorial statutes of 1851 said civil actions "must be commenced by the service of a summons, except as hereinafter provided." Today's Rule 3.01 says a civil action is commenced "when the summons is served upon that defendant". Same idea, 175 years later.
Lawyers call it hip-pocket filing: the case lives in the plaintiff's pocket until somebody files it. In 2011 the Supreme Court's own task force called Minnesota "an outlier (one of three states)". The state bar's 2023 report counted five states that still do it, Minnesota included, and Washington makes six. Of the bar's five, Minnesota gives the plaintiff the longest time to file: 365 days. You get 21 days to answer. A year for them, three weeks for you. The mechanics are in the piece on the lawsuit that was never filed.
1945 to 2009: garnishing before judgment, then without a filing
The garnishment half was built, and trimmed, a board at a time. By 1945 a garnishee summons could issue "at the time of issuing the summons". In 1976 the Legislature tied it to 40 days after service, once a default could be entered. In 1990 it wrote the no-filing sentence I opened with. In 2009 it made it 45 days and added a Notice of Intent to Garnish. Nobody has touched that clause since.
You're served at your door. Nothing is filed. The notice arrives. You don't answer in time. From day 45, the creditor's lawyer, not a judge, can prepare a garnishment summons for your employer.
1978: the day Minnesota's rate cap stopped mattering
When this fight started, Minnesota law fixed the interest on a bank credit card account at 12 percent a year. A Minneapolis bank went to Hennepin County District Court to stop a Nebraska national bank from selling Minnesotans its BankAmericard at Nebraska's rate, 18 percent on the first $999.99. The case, Marquette National Bank of Minneapolis v. First of Omaha Service Corp., went to the U.S. Supreme Court, and in December 1978 the Nebraska bank's side won: a national bank can charge the rate allowed by the state where it's located. The Court called the protection of state usury laws "an issue of legislative policy," and said any plea to change the federal statute was "better addressed to the wisdom of Congress than to the judgment of this Court."
Here's the part that gets me: that case was about Minnesota's own cap. Minnesota's own Attorney General intervened in the case on Marquette's side, joining its request for a declaratory judgment and a permanent injunction, and went down with it. Our cap lost. That's why, if your card comes from a national bank, the limit on its rate comes from the state the bank calls home.
2006 to 2009: a referee in St. Louis Park
Then came the National Arbitration Forum, on Wayzata Boulevard in St. Louis Park. Card lenders wrote it into the fine print. According to the State's July 14, 2009 complaint, a New York investment group bought a stake in the Forum and also funded the collection company that took over the assets and collection operations of Mann Bracken, a collection law firm. In 2006, Mann Bracken and Wolpoff & Abramson, two firms that later merged, filed 58 percent of the Forum's 214,000 consumer collection claims. The investors' pitch, as the complaint quotes it: "Arbitration should capture at least 50% of the volume currently placed in litigation". Those are allegations, and the Forum settled without admitting any of it.
A U.S. House staff report, working from the Forum's own records, counted 14,408 Forum arbitrations in Minnesota. Consumers filed 79 of them. That's 0.5 percent. Some forum.
After a year-long investigation, the Attorney General's office had the Forum out of consumer arbitration ten days after it sued, in State v. National Arbitration Forum, Inc.: filed July 14, and by consent judgment, no new consumer arbitrations as of July 24. It used the consumer-fraud laws already on the books. That one's to Minnesota's credit. Full story: the piece on the Forum.
Now the catch. Seventeen years later, Minnesota still hasn't enacted a general consumer-arbitration law. SF 4289, a bill to stop companies from requiring arbitration before or during a sale, cleared a Senate committee on April 7, 2026, went to a second one, and never came out. It died when the Legislature adjourned for the biennium on May 18, 2026. The state's best consumer-arbitration win is still what it was in 2009: one lawsuit.
2011 to 2013: the task force heard from the creditors
In 2011, when it took up pocket service, the task force wrote down the collection firms' own estimate: "50,000 non-filed consumer cases", about twice as many as had been filed.
I want to emphasize who made the case for waiting. The task force "heard from consumer collection attorneys representing creditors" who said the most common reason for waiting to file was giving consumers time to get back on their feet, and that keeping a debt off the court record and out of filing fees helps the consumer. That's their side, and it isn't crazy. A filing fee does end up on the bill. Lawyers for consumers answered that people in debt "suffer from having their cases simply hang out there".
The task force voted 16 to 4 for a one-year deadline to file. The Court adopted it in 2013 and picked the tougher option: an action not filed within a year is "deemed dismissed with prejudice", unless the parties agree in writing within that year to extend it. The Court put a clock on the hip pocket. It didn't empty it.
The same year, the Legislature did something that would be funny if it weren't the law. Instead of ending pocket service, it slapped a warning label on it, like a pack of cigarettes. Since September 1, 2013, the notice in § 548.101 tells you a lawsuit may be started against you even though "the court has no record of this lawsuit or this paperwork." It's right there in the session law. From 2013 through 2026, the Revisor's bill search turns up no bill to make a lawsuit start by filing, and none to stop garnishment on an unfiled suit.
2017: one tie vote
The federal government had already kept forced arbitration out of mortgages and out of consumer credit to service members. In 2017 the consumer bureau's rule would have stopped covered companies from using an arbitration clause to block class actions, and its Federal Register notice tipped its hat to Minnesota: the Forum had been "effectively shut down by the Minnesota Attorney General". Congress voided it. The Senate tied 50–50, and the Vice President broke the tie. Seven of Minnesota's ten members of Congress voted against killing it: both senators and five of eight House members. It died anyway.
2020 to 2025: the floor, the draft, and what passed
In 2020 the Legislature unanimously passed a change two Republicans had proposed the year before: the protected floor under a paycheck went to 40 times the state minimum wage. Good idea. Wrong wage. The one it pointed at was "$9.50 per hour beginning August 1, 2016". So from August 1, 2020 to June 30, 2025, almost five years, the floor sat at $380 a week. The 2025 special session finally fixed the pointer.
In 2024, three DFL bills started at a 10 percent cap with everything below 80 times the minimum wage protected. Conference sent back 25, 15 and 10 percent above 40 times. The commerce bill carrying it passed the Senate 34–32 and the House 70–58. Above $22.82 an hour, full time, it changed nothing: 25 percent, the federal maximum. It reaches only causes of action commenced on or after June 1, 2025. And the two levy statutes, §§ 550.136 and 551.06, still print a flat "25 percent".
For a lower-wage worker, those tiers are real help. At $18 an hour, figuring take-home pay at 80 percent of gross, a creditor now takes $86.40 a week instead of the federal maximum's $144. The Legislature helped that worker, then called it a day. The state-by-state numbers are in the October piece on what a paycheck loses.
2024 to 2026: who's suing, and what the president said
In 2024, by the Debt Collection Lab's count, one debt buyer, LVNV Funding, filed 17,471 of Minnesota's 60,765 debt suits. That's 28.8 percent, and the piece on the debt buyers has the rest of the list. The consumer bureau found charged-off card debt sold for an average of 11 percent of the balance in 2024. Eleven cents on the dollar. Texas, Pennsylvania and South Carolina won't let that paper touch a paycheck. Minnesota will, and the November piece on Texas runs the numbers.
Even Donald Trump says the rates are too high, and has since 2024. His words: Americans would no longer be "ripped off" by credit card companies (January 9, 2026). "The credit card companies have totally abused." (January 11). "Whatever happened to usury?" (January 21, at Davos).
He never called it a scam, not in any statement of his I found. That word's mine. It does turn up in Minnesota's record: the bar's stakeholder interviews say pocket-service papers may be viewed as a "scam" when the court has nothing on file. So I'll say it, and I mean the system. Buy a dead account for about a dime on the dollar. Sue on it without filing. If you don't answer, reach a paycheck before a judge has seen the case. Every step of that is legal in Minnesota. That's the scam.
His own consumer bureau went the other way. In April 2025 it agreed in a joint motion that its own late-fee rule "violated the CARD Act", and a federal judge vacated it the next day. A watchdog that agrees its own rule broke the law is a strange kind of watchdog. The piece on usury walks through the rest of its filings.
Minnesota's books still say a card's finance charge can't top 18 percent. A national bank doesn't have to care. That's the 1978 case. Federal law does leave a narrow door: a state can opt out of rate exportation for state-chartered banks and some other lenders, never for a national bank. Colorado and Oregon have walked through it. Minnesota's Attorney General signed the states' brief backing Colorado when its opt-out was challenged in the federal appeals court, in National Association of Industrial Bankers v. Weiser. Minnesota hasn't opened its own door. No Minnesota legislator filed an opt-out bill in 2025 or 2026. What the Legislature got instead was two card-rate bills, both led by one House member, in the last five weeks of the 2026 session, with no Senate companion and no hearing. One would cut the 18 percent cap to ten, but only "upon a change in federal law". The bill's own effective-date clause gives the game away: against a national bank, the cap is dead letter.
That's lip service
Add it up. For 175 years, a way of starting lawsuits that only a handful of states still allow. Since 1990, a statute that says in so many words a creditor needs no court filing to garnish on one. A deadline from the Court. A warning label from the Legislature. One great win over the arbitration machine, and still no statute behind it. A garnishment reform that went in at 10 percent and came out at 25 for anyone over $22.82 an hour, full time. A card-rate cap that's dead letter against a national bank, and in the last two sessions, not one opt-out bill that could bring part of it back.
A liberal state would have fixed half of this by now. Minnesota gave it lip service.
What we can do
Start a lawsuit by filing it. Washington wrote the rule for debt collectors; its legislature "intends to require that debt collection complaints be filed prior to service". Minnesota can do that for every case, or for debt cases first. At the very least, no garnishment until a complaint is on file.
Take the paycheck off the table for credit card and debt-buyer judgments, as Texas, Pennsylvania and South Carolina do. Failing that, pass the Legislature's own 2024 first draft pointed at today's wage, reach suits started before June 1, 2025, and write the tiers into §§ 550.136 and 551.06.
Write the 2009 win into law. SF 4289 is already drafted. Bring it back in 2027 and pass it.
File the opt-out, and get a card cap ready for the day Congress lets it bite. HF 5162 was written that way. Know what the opt-out reaches: never a national bank.
Count the garnishments. Every garnishment summons reported, by creditor, with the Judicial Branch publishing the totals every year. If a university lab can count the lawsuits, the state can count the paychecks.
And this part's on us. The bills I've named died with the 2026 session. Their text is still on the Revisor's site. The Campaign Finance Board publishes what lobbying groups report spending, year by year. When the Supreme Court took up the filing rule in 2012, it asked for public comments from "All persons" and held the window open until October 22. None of that is hidden.
This history is disgraceful, and we the people have allowed it. I'm counting myself in that. The fixes are written down. Somebody has to ask for them by name, because lip service is the one thing this state has never run short of.
Sources
Commencement and pocket service: Minn. R. Civ. P. 3.01 and 5.04(a), Revisor's court-rules copy; Revised Statutes of the Territory of Minnesota (1851), ch. 70, § 44; Minnesota Supreme Court Civil Justice Reform Task Force, Final Report (Dec. 23, 2011), pp. 21–23 and n. 8 (Legislative Reference Library); Minn. Sup. Ct. orders of July 17, 2012 (order for hearing), Sept. 20, 2012 (order extending public comment period) and Feb. 4, 2013 (order adopting amendments), Nos. ADM10-8051, ADM09-8009, ADM04-8001; RCW 19.16.250(27) and the findings of 2019 Wash. Laws ch. 201, § 1 (app.leg.wa.gov). All read November 6, 2026.
Garnishment and the statutes: Minn. Stat. §§ 571.71, 548.101, 571.922, 550.136, 551.06, 47.59 and 48.185, 2026 editions, revisor.mn.gov; Laws 1945, ch. 424, § 1; Laws 1976, ch. 335, § 12; Laws 1990, ch. 606, art. 3, § 1; Laws 2009, ch. 31, § 4; Laws 2013, ch. 104, § 3; Laws 2020, ch. 86, art. 4; Laws 2024, ch. 114, art. 3, § 101; Laws 2025, ch. 18, § 21; Laws 2025, 1st Spec. Sess., ch. 4, art. 7, §§ 32–34; 2022 edition of § 177.24. Bill text, history and votes for S.F. 1706, S.F. 3357, H.F. 4100, S.F. 4065, S.F. 4602, S.F. 4097, S.F. 4289, H.F. 4219, H.F. 5162 and H.F. 4951 from the Revisor's bill pages; session dates of the 94th Legislature from the Legislative Reference Library.
The 1978 decision: Marquette Nat'l Bank of Minneapolis v. First of Omaha Serv. Corp., 439 U.S. 299, 301–02, 304, 306, 308, 319 (1978); 12 U.S.C. §§ 85 and 1831d and Pub. L. 96-221, § 525, 94 Stat. 167 (govinfo.gov).
The Forum: the Minnesota Attorney General's complaint, Hennepin County District Court (July 14, 2009), and Consent Judgment, recitals and ¶ 3, State v. Nat'l Arbitration Forum, Inc., No. 27-CV-09-18550 (Minn. Dist. Ct. Hennepin Cnty.) (signed by the parties July 17, 2009); Arbitration or Arbitrary: The Misuse of Mandatory Arbitration to Collect Consumer Debts, House Subcommittee on Domestic Policy, Serial No. 111-125 (July 22, 2009), including the majority staff report, n. 8. Arbitration Agreements, 82 Fed. Reg. 33210 (July 19, 2017), at 33252; Pub. L. 115-74; 15 U.S.C. § 1639c(e) and 10 U.S.C. § 987(e)(3), (f)(4); House Roll Call 412 (July 25, 2017); Senate Roll Call Vote 249, 115th Cong., 1st Sess. (Oct. 24, 2017).
Lawsuits, prices and the bureau: Minnesota State Bar Association Access to Justice Committee, "Minnesota Consumer Debt Litigation: A Statewide Access to Justice Report" (October 2023), pp. 3, 4, 11, 12, 13, 28 and Table 4; Debt Collection Lab (Princeton), Lawsuit Tracker, Minnesota data file; Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "The Consumer Credit Card Market" (December 2025), p. 94; Credit Card Penalty Fees (Regulation Z), 89 Fed. Reg. 19128 (Mar. 15, 2024); Chamber of Commerce of the U.S. v. CFPB, No. 4:24-cv-00213-P (N.D. Tex.), ECF 149, ¶ 4 (Apr. 14, 2025), and ECF 150 (Apr. 15, 2025). Nat'l Ass'n of Indus. Bankers v. Weiser, 159 F.4th 694 (10th Cir. 2025) (listing counsel and amici), reh'g en banc granted and judgment vacated, No. 24-1293 (10th Cir. Apr. 2, 2026). The Colorado and Oregon opt-out acts (Colo. H.B. 23-1229; Or. Laws 2026, ch. 113) from the two legislatures' sites.
Presidential statements: Truth Social post of January 9, 2026, from the Internet Archive's capture of the post's own record; Daily Compilation of Presidential Documents DCPD-202600015 (January 11, 2026) and DCPD-202600046 (January 21, 2026), govinfo.gov.
Earlier pieces in this series: "In Minnesota, a Debt Lawsuit Can Start, and Reach Your Paycheck, Before Any Court Has a Record of It. In 2011, Collection Firms Put Their Unfiled Cases at 50,000." (November 6, 2026); "One Company Filed 17,471 Minnesota Debt Lawsuits in 2024. Two of the Biggest Debt Buyers in the Country Say a Third to Half of Their U.S. Money Comes Through the Courts." (November 6, 2026); "'Whatever Happened to Usury?' The President Asked. His Own Consumer Bureau's Filings Answer It, and Minnesota Has a Door It Has Never Opened." (November 6, 2026); "Three States Won't Let a Credit Card Company Touch Your Paycheck. Minnesota's Legislature Wrote a 10 Percent Cap in 2024, Then Passed Something Else." (November 6, 2026); "Minnesota Lets a Creditor Take $240 a Week From a $30-an-Hour Paycheck. In Texas, the Answer Is Zero." (October 20, 2026); "It Ran Out of St. Louis Park, and Minnesota Shut It Down in Ten Days. Seventeen Years Later, There's Still No Law Behind That Win." (November 6, 2026).
What I could not establish. No record I found shows who first proposed garnishment on an unfiled suit, or that any group lobbied to create or keep pocket service; the record shows what creditors' collection attorneys told the 2011 task force, which is what I quoted. The 2012 public comments to the Supreme Court were not retrievable, so I can't say who filed them. The count of serve-first states comes from the 2023 bar report plus Washington's statute, not a fifty-state survey. The Forum figures are the Attorney General's allegations and a congressional staff report; the Forum admitted nothing. The opt-out search covered the 2025–2026 bill database, not earlier sessions. No public record counts Minnesota wage garnishments. Whether a Minnesota opt-out would survive a court challenge, and what Colorado's pending case will decide, are legal questions this piece does not answer. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.