Congratulations to Keith Ellison. On the complete unofficial count, as of 9:06 a.m. Wednesday, he beat Ron Schutz 1,520,397 to 1,275,393. That's 54.30 percent to 45.55, a margin of 245,004 votes. Four years ago he won by 20,815.

So what happened in between? Here's my read. I think Minnesota voters just indicted the Trump administration for Operation Metro Surge. Nobody's ballot asked about it, so that's my opinion, not a finding. Below is everything it rests on, plus the parts of the record that cut against me.

One plain disclosure before the facts. I ran against Keith Ellison in the August primary and lost. I've also said publicly that I'm supporting him in this one. Weigh what follows with that in mind. Everything below comes from records you can open yourself, and they're listed at the bottom.

What the government said it did

Start with the name, because a lot of people skip it. The federal government called it "Operation Metro Surge". The director of ICE's St. Paul field office swore in a declaration filed January 19 that it "launched in early December 2025." He gave the mission too: "to significantly increase 'at-large' arrests of illegal aliens in the Twin Cities metropolitan area, focusing on individuals with executable final orders."

Then the size. Same declaration: "In the Twin Cities of St. Paul and Minneapolis, ERO has approximately 80 officers." On January 26, Judge Katherine Menendez asked how many were here now. The Justice Department answered in writing that "there are currently approximately 3,000 officers and agents with ICE and CBP conducting immigration enforcement actions in the greater Minneapolis area."

I read that filing twice. It isn't a press release. It's the government's own lawyers answering a federal judge. Eighty, then about 3,000. The judge did the same math in her order: about 3,000 federal officers "in contrast to the 80 officers that '[t]ypically' cover ICE’s operations in the Twin Cities."

The arrests climbed right along with it. The January 19 declaration says ICE "has arrested more than 3,000 illegal aliens." On February 4 the Department of Homeland Security announced "more than 4,000 arrests of illegal aliens". The declaration also says "approximately 66,000 aliens in Minnesota appear to be or may be subject to enforcement actions".

The government's side belongs here too, read straight. ICE's declaration calls this "an exclusive federal operation" enforcing federal immigration law. The White House's February 4 release says the policies were "delivering the public safety results the American people demanded". That's their best case. It's a real argument about federal law. It just didn't sell in Minnesota.

And then it was over. A February 13 memo from the White House budget director says: "On Thursday, February 12, Tom Homan announced the end of Operation Metro Surge." Early December to February 12. About ten weeks.

Two people killed

On January 7, Minnesota's brief in its evidence suit says, "ICE Agent Jonathan Ross shot and killed 37-year-old U.S. citizen Renee Good in her car on a residential street in Minneapolis." On January 14, the Hennepin County Attorney's charges say, an ICE agent fired through the front door of a north Minneapolis home and hit Julio Sosa-Celis in the leg. On January 24, the same brief says, "federal immigration agents shot and killed U.S. citizen Alex Jeffrey Pretti on a public street in Minneapolis".

Judge Menendez said it in one line on January 31: "Since Operation Metro Surge began, there have been multiple shootings of Minnesota residents by federal immigration enforcement agents."

As of the Hennepin County Attorney's report to the Governor's Minnesota Truth Council, dated October 20, nobody had been charged in either death. The report says: "Because the federal government continues to obstruct our efforts in investigating the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti, our litigation is ongoing." The State has charged two ICE agents in incidents where nobody died: one with second-degree assault after a confrontation on Highway 62, and the agent who fired in the Sosa-Celis shooting. Those are charges. Both men are presumed innocent.

What the judges said

Minnesota sued to stop the operation on January 12, and it lost the first round. Read the loss in Judge Menendez's own words, because of what she said first.

She wrote that "Plaintiffs have made a strong showing that Operation Metro Surge has had, and will likely continue to have, profound and even heartbreaking, consequences on the State of Minnesota, the Twin Cities, and Minnesotans." She wrote that the government did "nothing to refute the negative impacts described by Plaintiffs in almost every arena of daily life". Then she denied the injunction. She held that Minnesota and the two cities hadn't shown they were likely to win on their Tenth Amendment and equal-sovereignty claims, so Plaintiffs "have not met their burden." The government's motion to dismiss was argued September 9, and the docket shows no ruling through its last entry on September 29.

Chief Judge Patrick Schiltz, in a separate habeas case, wrote on January 28. He attached "an appendix that identifies 96 court orders that ICE has violated in 74 cases", and wrote that "ICE has likely violated more court orders in January 2026 than some federal agencies have violated in their entire existence." A few lines later: "ICE is not a law unto itself." Ninety-six orders, all issued since New Year's Day. That number stopped me cold.

On January 20 the Justice Department served grand-jury subpoenas on the records custodians for the Governor, the mayors of Minneapolis and St. Paul, the Attorney General, and the Ramsey and Hennepin County boards. Chief Judge Schiltz quashed them in June. He wrote of "overwhelming evidence that these subpoenas were not issued to investigate, but to harass, coerce, and retaliate."

The rest of the litigation is in the docket list I built for this series.

"Invasion" was Minnesota's word, and she wasn't the ICE chief

You'll hear this called an invasion. That's Minnesota's word, not Washington's. The State's complaint says "Operation Metro Surge is, in essence, a federal invasion of the Twin Cities." Ellison's statement the day he sued says "This federal invasion of the Twin Cities has to stop". The City of Minneapolis wrote that "up to 3,000 federal immigration enforcement agents invaded neighborhoods".

On every record I found, no federal troops came. Governor Walz's Executive Order 26-01, signed January 8, told the Adjutant General to bring Minnesota National Guard personnel to state active duty, and said the Guard should act "only where local law enforcement resources have been exhausted." Those were state orders. The State's complaint says the President claimed "the absolute right" to invoke the Insurrection Act. I found no proclamation invoking it, and no federalization or Title 10 deployment order for Minnesota, on whitehouse.gov, defense.gov, the Federal Register or any docket I read. Judge Menendez left whether a Guard deployment would violate the Tenth Amendment among the "questions for another day." The White House, for its part, used the same word aimed the other way. Its February 4 release says Democrats "allowed vicious criminals, including murderers, rapists, gang members, and terrorists, to invade our communities." Everybody grabbed the same word. No court order I read uses it for the operation.

Same with calling Kristi Noem the ICE chief. Noem was Secretary of Homeland Security, the cabinet officer over ICE, Customs and Border Protection and the rest. ICE itself was run by its Acting Director, Todd Lyons, who's named in the State's suit. Today ICE's leadership page lists David J. Venturella as "Senior Official Performing the Duties of the Director". And Noem's gone. DHS says the Senate confirmed Markwayne Mullin as Secretary "in a bipartisan vote of 54-45", and its Secretary page says he "was sworn in as the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security on March 24th, 2026." That's more than seven months before Election Day.

Her story, and the prosecutors'

This is the one I can't get past.

On January 15 DHS put out a release on the Sosa-Celis shooting. It quotes Secretary Noem: "What we saw last night in Minneapolis was an attempted murder of federal law enforcement. Our officer was ambushed and attacked by three individuals who beat him with snow shovels and the handles of brooms. Fearing for his life, the officer fired a defensive shot". Federal prosecutors charged two of the men, and the FBI agent's affidavit behind that complaint told the same shovel-and-broom story.

On February 11 the U.S. Attorney's Office for Minnesota, the same administration's prosecutors, moved to drop that case. "Newly discovered evidence in this matter is materially inconsistent with the allegations in the Complaint Affidavit," the motion says. Judge Paul Magnuson dismissed the charge "with prejudice" on February 13.

On May 18 Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty's office, working with the Attorney General's Office, charged the agent, Christian Castro, with four counts of second-degree assault and one count of falsely reporting a crime. Her office's release says: "Contrary to the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) press release on January 15, Mr. Castro was not hit with any shovels, brooms, or weapons of any kind at any time during this incident." The complaint says city camera video shows the shovel tossed "onto the ground, where it remained throughout the incident". The Attorney General's Office reports that the U.S. Attorney later charged Castro with "six counts of making materially false statements to the FBI". He's presumed innocent on all of it.

No court has found that Noem lied, or that she knew the story was wrong when DHS put her name on it. What the record does show is two prosecutors, one federal and one state, filing papers that don't square with her account. And that January 15 release is still sitting on dhs.gov this morning. Uncorrected.

It wasn't the only number that wobbled. DHS's January 19 release quotes her: "We have arrested over 10,000 criminal illegal aliens", and in her next sentence, "In the last 6 weeks, our brave DHS law enforcement have arrested 3,000 criminal illegal aliens". Only the second figure lines up with anything filed under oath, and the sworn declaration says "illegal aliens", not "criminal illegal aliens". Judge Menendez wrote that the group included "an unspecified number of people with a variety of criminal convictions."

What the two candidates said

Ellison sued on January 12. His statement that day: "The unlawful deployment of thousands of armed, masked, and poorly trained federal agents is hurting Minnesota". On March 4, under oath before the House Oversight Committee, he said the administration, "on the pretext of fighting fraud, unleashed over 3,000 masked armed agents on the streets of Minnesota, and as a result, two U.S. citizens were killed by Federal agents, Renee Good and Alex Pretti." He added: "Federal law enforcement still refuses to cooperate with us in investigating their deaths." When the end was announced, he said: "The end of Operation Metro Surge, when it materializes, will be welcome news. Tragically, the surge is ending too late for Renee Good and Alex Pretti and all who loved them."

Schutz put out a statement on January 26, two days after Pretti was killed. "Now, in the wake of a federal law enforcement operation following years of loose enforcement of our nation’s immigration laws, we are in the news for the death of two individuals." He wrote that "Renee Good and Alex Pretti had family and friends who will never see them again", and that "We must also remember that law enforcement officers put their lives on the line for us every day." His plan: "If I were Attorney General, I would use the influence of the office to coordinate between federal and local authorities to ensure clear communication, lawful cooperation, and accountability, while working closely with Hennepin County officials and community leaders to reduce tensions and protect public safety." And: "Minnesotans are entitled to a complete and thorough investigation of these shootings. And that investigation needs to be a joint effort between Federal and cooperative local law enforcement officials." Later his campaign site went after Ellison's Senate testimony, saying Ellison "told members of the United States Senate that left-wing protesters did not obstruct ICE, nor did he cheer them on", and listing examples it said proved otherwise. His priorities page says: "I will stand with law enforcement, restore respect for those who protect our communities".

Put those side by side and, to my eye, you've got the race. One candidate sued the operation. The other promised to coordinate between federal and local authorities and called for a joint investigation. That's a real choice, and voters made it.

What voters said, and what nobody asked them

I found exactly one election survey of Minnesota: the Fox News Voter Poll, run by SSRS from October 19 through November 3. It asked about the President and about ICE. It didn't ask about the Attorney General's race, Noem or Metro Surge.

Trump job approval in Minnesota: 37 approve, 62 disapprove, on 3,881 respondents. ICE: 38 approve, 62 disapprove. Asked whether "the Trump administration's actions on immigration enforcement" had gone too far, 59 percent said "Gone too far", 21 percent "Not gone far enough", and 20 percent "Been about right". The ICE and immigration questions went to 1,267 respondents.

Take that with a grain of salt. The same respondents say they voted Harris over Trump 50 to 42 in 2024. The Secretary of State's 2024 results file has Minnesota at 50.92 to 46.68. This crowd remembers 2024 a little bluer than the ballots do.

Then the unofficial count. Statewide, Ellison's two-candidate margin moved 7.93 points toward him from 2022. In the seven-county metro it moved 9.04. Outside it, 5.22. Anoka, Carlton, Rice and Winona all flipped to Ellison. Hennepin and Ramsey together moved 8.77, a bit more than the state. The five suburban metro counties moved most of all, 9.46.

Here's how I'd know I blew this one

The Attorney General's race moved with the whole ticket. By county, Ellison's 2026 margin and Amy Klobuchar's margin in the governor's race correlate at 0.999. Ellison's margin trailed Klobuchar's in all 87 counties. On the unofficial count, Klobuchar beat Lisa Demuth 55.47 to 42.63. If voters were handing down a separate verdict in the Attorney General's race, you'd expect Ellison to beat the top of the ticket somewhere. He didn't. So this swing is at least as much about the national mood as about this office.

Homan announced the end of the operation February 12. The election was November 3. In SurveyUSA's September 9 to 14 poll for KSTP, seven months after Homan announced the end, Schutz led 45 to 43. The same pollster's final poll, October 24 to 28, had Ellison up 49 to 41. A lot of whatever moved this race moved it in the last seven weeks.

And when I say the President failed to rein this in, that's my framing, not a finding. The White House's own February 4 release says Homan's commitment to draw down forces came "At President Trump’s direction". The record shows the operation ending after about ten weeks, after two people were killed, after a chief judge listed 96 violated orders. It doesn't show anybody asking the President to stop and him refusing.

One piece of the count is arguably the office's own, and it's small. In 2022 Ellison ran about 7 points behind Tim Walz statewide. This time he ran about 4.3 behind Klobuchar. The gap narrowed. That's all.

So here's my verdict, and I'll own it. I think Minnesotans remembered January, and they voted against the people who ran it. I think a 59 percent "Gone too far" is what an indictment sounds like when nobody hands you a ballot question. The record can't prove that. It can show you what voters had in front of them.

What we can do

None of this needs a new law. It needs somebody to act on what the government's own lawyers already filed.

Correct the January 15 release. The U.S. Attorney walked away from that case, with prejudice, in February. The Hennepin County Attorney charged the agent in May. DHS can append a correction to its own page this afternoon. It costs nothing.

Share the evidence on Good and Pretti. Here both candidates agree, in writing. Schutz called for "a joint effort between Federal and cooperative local law enforcement officials." Ellison testified that federal law enforcement "still refuses to cooperate with us". Minnesota's suit for that evidence is waiting on a ruling in federal court in Washington. The Justice Department doesn't need a ruling to send the files.

Keep the body cameras on, and publish the count. In January ICE swore that "body worn cameras (BWCs) have not been implemented for ICE officers out of the ERO St. Paul Office." In March Noem's written statement to the House Judiciary Committee said DHS "has accelerated deployment of these cameras for federal agents and officers in Minneapolis to increase accountability". Good. Tell us how many, and keep them rolling.

Congratulations again to Keith Ellison. He's got another term and a docket full of cases from those ten weeks. I hope he wins every one the record supports.

First the facts. Then the fix.


Sources

The operation's name, launch, mission, staffing, arrest count and the 66,000 figure are from the Declaration of Samuel J. Olson, Field Office Director, ICE ERO St. Paul, filed January 19, 2026 in State of Minnesota v. Noem (now v. Mullin), No. 26-cv-190 (KMM/DJF) (D. Minn.), ECF 35-2, ¶¶ 14–17, 19 and 20. The 3,000 figure is the government's January 26, 2026 response to the court's question, ECF 120. Judge Menendez's findings and the denial are from her January 31, 2026 order, ECF 135, at 2, 4, 19 n.14, 28 and 30; the motion-to-dismiss argument date is from the court's docket as indexed by CourtListener (RECAP). Minnesota's complaint (ECF 1, filed January 12, 2026, ¶ 3 and ¶ 201) was read as posted by the Attorney General's Office. Chief Judge Schiltz's order is Juan T.R. v. Noem, No. 26-cv-0107 (PJS/DLM) (D. Minn. Jan. 28, 2026), ECF 10, as posted by the Attorney General's Office. The subpoena ruling is In re Grand Jury Subpoenas, No. 26-mc-43 (PJS) (D. Minn.), order dated June 17, 2026 and unsealed June 22, 2026, at 25. The Good and Pretti passages are from Minnesota's memorandum in support of summary judgment in Minnesota v. U.S. Department of Justice, No. 1:26-cv-01007 (EGS) (D.D.C.), ECF 27-1, at 7 and 13. The federal case is United States v. Aljorna, No. 26-mj-23 (PAM/DLM) (D. Minn.): ECF 1-1 (FBI affidavit in support of the criminal complaint, filed January 16, 2026), ECF 48 (motion, February 11, 2026) and ECF 49 (order, February 13, 2026). The Castro charges and camera timeline are from the Hennepin County Attorney's May 18, 2026 release and the criminal complaint in State v. Castro, No. 27-CR-26-12537, as posted by the Attorney General's Office; the federal charge is as described in the Attorney General's September 17, 2026 release. The Hennepin County Attorney's statement on the Good and Pretti investigations is from its report to the Minnesota Truth Council dated October 20, 2026, at 15. The Highway 62 charge is from the Attorney General's April 16, 2026 statement.

The DHS releases of January 15, January 19, February 4 and March 24, 2026, the DHS Secretary page and the ICE Leadership page were read at dhs.gov and ice.gov on November 4, 2026; the January 15 release was live that morning. The White House release of February 4, 2026 was read at whitehouse.gov, and OMB Memorandum M-26-08 (February 13, 2026) at whitehouse.gov. Executive Order 26-01 was read at mn.gov. Ellison's January 12 and February 12, 2026 statements are from the Attorney General's Office releases. His March 4, 2026 testimony is from the Government Publishing Office transcript of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform hearing that day, at 8. Noem's March 4, 2026 written statement is from the House Judiciary Committee's posted copy. The City of Minneapolis figure is from its February 13, 2026 release. Schutz's statements are from his campaign site, ronformnag.com: the January 26, 2026 release on the latest situation in Minneapolis, the "Keith Ellison Flip-Flops" page, and his priorities page, read November 4, 2026.

The survey figures are from the Fox News Voter Poll's Minnesota results page at foxnews.com, read November 4, 2026, including the page's description of how the poll was conducted. The SurveyUSA figures are from the pollster's September and October 2026 releases for KSTP, as set out in my earlier piece on the polls. The 2026 results are from the Secretary of State's unofficial result files at electionresultsfiles.sos.mn.gov (attorneygen.txt, Governor.txt and the all-races-by-county file), as they stood at 9:06 a.m. Central on Wednesday, November 4, 2026, with all 4,105 precincts reporting. The 2022 results are from the State Canvassing Board's certificate. The 2024 presidential figures are from the Secretary of State's 2024 results file. The swings, regional totals, flips, correlations and county comparisons are my arithmetic on those records.

What I searched, what I found, and what I could not establish. I found no Minnesota election survey other than the Fox News Voter Poll, and no AP VoteCast Minnesota release; nothing I found asked voters about the Attorney General's race, Operation Metro Surge or Kristi Noem. I found no proclamation, federalization order or Title 10 order for Minnesota on whitehouse.gov, defense.gov, the Federal Register or in any docket I read. The President's social-media posts could not be opened directly, so this piece relies on the court filings for his words. I found no document showing what Noem knew when the January 15 release went out. The Hennepin County Attorney's statement on the Good and Pretti investigations is as of its October 20 report. The 2026 figures are unofficial until the State Canvassing Board certifies them. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.

Related research

Chosen by shared subject and shared statute, not by date.

Minnesota by the Numbers

Keith Ellison's Office Says It Has Sued the Administration 75 Times. Ron Schutz Says Most of Those Cases Were Filed Somewhere Else. I Built the Docket List. They're Both Right, and the Count Is Higher.

At their MPR debate, Keith Ellison's office put its lawsuits against the Trump administration at 75, and Ron Schutz said most were filed outside Minnesota with…

Minnesota by the Numbers

The Same Pollster Had the Republican Up 7 in 2022, and He Lost. Here's Every 2026 Poll of the Attorney General Race, Then the Count.

SurveyUSA's last 2022 poll had Jim Schultz up 7 points. Keith Ellison won by 20,815 votes. Its last 2026 poll has Ellison up 8 on Ron Schutz. I pulled every…

Minnesota by the Numbers

Minnesota Has Elected an Attorney General 21 Times Since 1954. Seven Times the Governor's Race Went the Other Way, and Every Time, the Attorney General Was the DFL Candidate.

I read the official canvass for every Minnesota Attorney General election from 1954 through 2022 and put each one next to the governor's race on the same ballot.…

← PreviousWhy I'm with Anders Folk2 of 2 in From Dave

All of From Dave →  •  The Dashboard →  •  The Receipts: every source →  •  The Platform →

Get the next one

New sourced research on Minnesota law, and the deadlines that matter before November 3. Every claim carries its source.

Subscribe Vote 2026: every deadline →

Discussion

Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.