On November 6, 1962, Minnesota held a governor's race so close it took a three-judge court until March 21, 1963 to call it. The court's statewide totals: Karl F. Rolvaag 619,842, Elmer L. Andersen 619,751. Ninety-one votes. Andersen kept the office until Rolvaag was sworn in on March 25.
On the same ballot, Walter F. Mondale won the attorney general's race by 236,162 votes, 730,783 to 494,621.
Same voters. Same day. One race went to a courtroom. The other wasn't close. That's the attorney general's office in one picture. It shares a ballot with the governor, and Minnesotans have never once treated it like the governor's opening act.
One plain disclosure before the facts. I ran against Keith Ellison in the August primary and lost. I've also said publicly that I'm supporting him in this one. Weigh what follows with that in mind. Everything below comes from records you can open yourself, and they're listed at the bottom.
With all 4,105 precincts in, the Secretary of State's unofficial count has Ellison ahead, 54.30 percent to 45.55. The number to quote is the one the State Canvassing Board certifies later this month.
Twenty-one elections, side by side
Minnesota used to elect its attorney general every two years. In 1958 the voters changed that. The second constitutional amendment on that year's ballot asked whether the governor, lieutenant governor, secretary of state, treasurer and attorney general should be elected "for four year terms beginning with the general election in 1962". It passed, 641,887 to 382,505. So from 1962 on, the attorney general and the governor have shared a ballot every four years, like it or not. Counting 2026, that's 21 general elections for attorney general since 1954.
Here's every one of them, from the official canvass in the Legislative Manuals and the Secretary of State's election books, with the governor's race from the same ballot.
| Year | Attorney General: winner, party, margin | Governor: winner, party, margin | AG minus governor |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1954 | Miles Lord, DFL, +5.48 | Orville L. Freeman, DFL, +5.93 | −0.44 |
| 1956 | Miles Lord, DFL, +0.42 | Orville L. Freeman, DFL, +3.23 | −2.82 |
| 1958 | Miles Lord, DFL, +11.49 | Orville L. Freeman, DFL, +14.45 | −2.96 |
| 1960 | Walter F. Mondale, DFL, +16.49 | Elmer L. Andersen, R, +1.48 | +17.97 |
| 1962 | Walter F. Mondale, DFL, +19.27 | Karl F. Rolvaag, DFL, 91 votes | +19.26 |
| 1966 | Douglas M. Head, R, +6.44 | Harold LeVander, R, +5.61 | −0.83 |
| 1970 | Warren Spannaus, DFL, +2.72 | Wendell R. Anderson, DFL, +8.51 | −5.78 |
| 1974 | Warren Spannaus, DFL, +31.90 | Wendell R. Anderson, DFL, +33.45 | −1.55 |
| 1978 | Warren Spannaus, DFL, +16.04 | Al Quie, IR, +7.05 | +23.09 |
| 1982 | Hubert H. Humphrey III, DFL, +24.48 | Rudy Perpich, DFL, +18.89 | +5.59 |
| 1986 | Hubert H. Humphrey III, DFL, +41.82 | Rudy Perpich, DFL, +13.02 | +28.80 |
| 1990 | Hubert H. Humphrey III, DFL, +26.44 | Arne Carlson, IR, +3.34 | +29.79 |
| 1994 | Hubert H. Humphrey III, DFL, +37.43 | Arne Carlson, IR, +29.22 | +66.66 |
| 1998 | Mike Hatch, DFL, +3.99 | Jesse Ventura, Reform, +2.70 | +10.20 |
| 2002 | Mike Hatch, DFL, +13.83 | Tim Pawlenty, R, +7.92 | +21.75 |
| 2006 | Lori Swanson, DFL, +12.52 | Tim Pawlenty, R, +0.96 | +13.48 |
| 2010 | Lori Swanson, DFL, +11.63 | Mark Dayton, DFL, +0.42 | +11.22 |
| 2014 | Lori Swanson, DFL, +13.59 | Mark Dayton, DFL, +5.56 | +8.03 |
| 2018 | Keith Ellison, DFL, +3.89 | Tim Walz, DFL, +11.42 | −7.53 |
| 2022 | Keith Ellison, DFL, +0.84 | Tim Walz, DFL, +7.66 | −6.83 |
| 2026 (unofficial) | Keith Ellison, DFL, +8.75 | Amy Klobuchar, DFL, +12.84 | −4.09 |
A word on reading it. Each margin is the winner's lead over the runner-up, in points of every vote the canvass prints for that office. The last column compares the two parties, not the two winners: it's the DFL candidate's margin over the Republican for attorney general, minus the same number for governor. A plus means the DFL's attorney general candidate ran ahead of the DFL's candidate for governor. A minus means behind. The Republican Party appears in the canvass as "Independent-Republican" from 1978 through 1994, and I count it as Republican throughout. Jesse Ventura's party is listed as the Reform Party. And in 1990 the canvass prints a separate line for Jon Grunseth, who it says withdrew as the IR nominee on October 29 and was replaced by Arne Carlson.
The split always goes one way
Seven times, Minnesota elected an attorney general and a governor from different parties: 1960, 1978, 1990, 1994, 1998, 2002 and 2006. Every one of those seven times, the attorney general was the DFL candidate and the governor wasn't.
The reverse never happened. Not once in 21 elections has Minnesota picked a DFL governor and a Republican attorney general. Not once.
And these weren't coin flips that landed differently down the ballot. In 1994 Arne Carlson won the governor's race by 29.22 points. On the same ballot Hubert H. Humphrey III won the attorney general's race by 37.43. That's a 66.66-point gap between two lines on one ballot.
In 1978 Al Quie beat Rudy Perpich for governor by 7.05 points while Warren Spannaus won his third term by 16.04. In 2006 Tim Pawlenty beat the sitting attorney general, Mike Hatch, for governor by 21,108 votes, and Lori Swanson won the open attorney general's seat by 12.52 points on the same ballot.
The one Republican attorney general in the whole stretch is Douglas M. Head, elected in 1966. The 1967–1968 Legislative Manual lists him as "Rep." He won by 6.44 points the same year Harold LeVander won the governor's race for the Republicans by 5.61. In 1970 Head ran for governor instead, and lost to Wendell R. Anderson by 116,141 votes. Spannaus won the open attorney general's race that year, 680,479 to 644,390, and took office January 4, 1971. The DFL has won every attorney general's race since. With this year's unofficial count, that's 15 in a row. Some franchises would kill for that.
The other streak
Everybody knows the DFL holds this office. The streak I didn't know about until I built the table is hiding in the last column.
From 1978 through 2014, ten straight elections, the DFL's candidate for attorney general ran ahead of the DFL's candidate for governor. Humphrey ran 28.80 points ahead of Perpich in 1986. Swanson ran 11.22 ahead of Dayton in 2010, the year the State Canvassing Board certified Dayton's own race on December 8 at 919,232 to 910,462, a lead of 8,770 votes. For almost four decades the attorney general's line ran ahead of the top of the DFL ticket.
Then it flipped, and it's stayed flipped. In 2018, 2022 and 2026, the DFL's attorney general candidate ran behind the top of the ticket: by 7.53 points in 2018, 6.83 in 2022, and 4.09 on this year's unofficial count.
Now the part I'd rather skip, given who I said I'm supporting. All three of those are Keith Ellison's races. He's the second attorney general in this record to run behind his party's governor candidate three times. The first was Miles Lord, who ran behind Orville Freeman in 1954, 1956 and 1958, by 0.44, 2.82 and 2.96 points. Lord won all three. So has Ellison. But the gap is real, and it's shown up every time Ellison has been on the ballot. If somebody tells you this office just rides the top of the ticket, they're reading three elections, not 21.
The same fact reads the other way for Ron Schutz. On the unofficial count, he got 69,605 more votes than Lisa Demuth did for governor, 1,275,393 to 1,205,788. Ellison got 48,697 fewer than Amy Klobuchar, 1,520,397 to 1,569,094. They don't have to match: the governor's race had a third candidate, Steven Young, with 51,384 votes, and the attorney general's race had none.
What 2026 did to the streaks
On the unofficial count, the DFL's hold on the office reached 15 straight elections. The last Republican to win it is still Head, in 1966.
The gap between the two races got smaller. Not gone. Smaller. Ellison ran 4.09 points behind Klobuchar, against 6.83 behind Tim Walz in 2022 and 7.53 in 2018. Measured as a share of the two-party vote, which is how I measured it county by county in the polls piece, it's 4.33 points this year against 7.07 in 2022.
And the gap shows up everywhere. I mean everywhere. On the unofficial county file, Ellison's two-party margin ran behind Klobuchar's in all 87 counties. The smallest gap was Red Lake, 0.26 points. The biggest was Carver, 6.95. In 2022 Ellison ran behind Walz in 81 counties and ahead of him in six. This year the gap shrank from 2022 in 65 of 87 counties, and it didn't close in any of them.
The split streak held too, in its own way. The last time Minnesota elected a governor and an attorney general from different parties was 2006. That's five straight elections, 2010 through 2026, with both offices going DFL.
How close is close, settled
My polls piece left one question open. You'll hear the 2022 race, Ellison over Jim Schultz by 20,815 votes and 0.84 points, called the closest since 1956. I hadn't read the totals for most of the elections in between, so I wouldn't sign my name to it.
Now I have. It holds up. The only attorney general's race in this record closer than 2022 is 1956, when Lord beat Keith Kennedy by 5,763 votes, 0.42 points. The next closest after 2022 is Spannaus over Robert A. Forsythe in 1970, at 2.72. Then Ellison over Doug Wardlow in 2018 at 3.89, and Hatch over Charlie Weaver in 1998 at 3.99.
One more thing turned up in the old books, and it made me laugh. The 1957–1958 Legislative Manual prints Orville Freeman's 1956 total for governor as 781,180. The 2011–2012 Manual's table of every governor's race since 1857 prints it as 731,180. Only the second number fits: that same manual says 1,443,856 ballots were cast and counted, and 781,180 plus Ancher Nelsen's 685,196 is already more than that. I used 731,180. Even the official record fat-fingers a number now and then. That's why you read two of them.
Fewer people vote in this race
In the printed totals, every one of the 21 elections has fewer votes for attorney general than for governor. The gap runs from 0.36 percent of the governor's vote in 1990 to 3.98 percent in 1998. This year, on the unofficial count, 2,828,740 people voted for governor and 2,800,012 for attorney general. That's 28,728 votes cast for governor that never made it down to the attorney general's line.
That's not a scandal. Races further down the ballot always shed a few votes, and this one sheds fewer than you'd guess. But every one of those 28,728 people lives under whoever wins the job they skipped.
Three sitting attorneys general were nominated for governor
This one surprised me. In this record, three sitting attorneys general won their party's nomination for governor. All three lost in November. At least two more ran while in office and never got that far. Warren Spannaus lost the 1982 DFL primary to Rudy Perpich, 275,920 to 248,218. Lori Swanson finished third in the 2018 DFL primary, with 143,517 votes to Tim Walz's 242,832.
Head ran in 1970 and lost to Anderson. Humphrey ran in 1998 and finished third behind Ventura and Norm Coleman, with 587,060 votes. Hatch ran in 2006 and lost to Pawlenty by 21,108. Each of them had won the attorney general's office at least once, and none of them could carry it into the governor's race.
Why? The canvass doesn't say. It just shows voters who liked a person as attorney general and wouldn't hand that person the bigger job. That fits everything else in the table. Minnesotans grade this office on its own curve.
What the numbers mean for the office
Take the parties off and here's what 21 elections say. Minnesotans vote for attorney general as a separate job. They've split it from the governor seven times, by as much as 66 points. They've elected an attorney general by 19 points the same day the governor's race went to a courtroom. They've nominated the sitting attorney general for governor three times and turned him down three times.
So quit reading the attorney general's race off the top of the ticket. For ten elections the attorney general ran ahead of it. For the last three he ran behind it. Neither pattern lasted forever, and neither one was about the governor.
The fix doesn't need a bill. It needs candidates and the people who cover them to treat this office the way its voters do: as a job with its own record, run on its own terms, and judged on its own line of the ballot. The voters figured that out in 1960. The canvass has been saying so ever since, to anybody who bothers to read it.
When the State Canvassing Board certifies this year's result, the 2026 row gets the certified numbers.
First the facts. Then the fix.
Sources
The 1954 through 2018 results are from the official canvass tables in the Minnesota Legislative Manuals and the Secretary of State's biennial "Minnesota Election Results" books, as posted by the Legislative Reference Library at lrl.mn.gov (archive/sessions/electionresults/, one PDF per general election), read on November 3 and 4, 2026. For 1954, 1956, 1958, 1970 and 1974 the figures are the statewide summary pages; for 1960, 1962, 1966, 1978 through 2010, 2014 and 2018 they are the TOTAL rows of the county tables. The 1962 governor totals are the district court's figures, printed in the 1962 State Canvassing Board report in the 1963–1964 Legislative Manual, which also gives the March 21 and March 25, 1963 dates; William Braatz's 7,234 votes are the Board's amended figure from the same page. The 1958 constitutional amendment vote is from the 1959–1960 Legislative Manual. The 1956 governor total of 731,180 is from the table "Minnesota Vote for Governor Since 1857" in the 2011–2012 Legislative Manual; the 1957–1958 Manual prints 781,180 on its summary page, against 1,443,856 ballots cast and counted on the same page. The 2010 governor totals are the State Canvassing Board's December 8, 2010 certification, as printed in the 2011–2012 Manual. Douglas Head's party is from the 1967–1968 Manual's county table ("D. M. Head Rep."). The dates the officeholders took office are from the Library's roster, "Minnesota Territorial and State Attorneys General, 1849-present". The 1982 and 2018 primary results are from the Library's posted returns for the September 14, 1982 and August 14, 2018 state primaries.
The 2022 results are from the State Canvassing Board Certificate for the 2022 state general election (filed November 29, 2022), read through the Internet Archive's copy of officialdocuments.sos.mn.gov, document 133584. The 2026 results are from the Secretary of State's election-night result files at electionresultsfiles.sos.mn.gov (the statewide Attorney General and Governor files and the all-races-by-county file), read at 9:06 a.m. Central on November 4, 2026, with all 4,105 precincts reporting. They are unofficial.
The margins, the AG-minus-governor column, the vote drop-off and the county comparisons are my arithmetic on those records. Margins are computed on every vote the canvass prints for the office, including minor-party candidates and, where the table prints them, write-ins; the 2018 tables don't print write-ins, so both 2018 races exclude them. The county comparisons use each county's two-party margin.
What I searched, what I found, and what I could not establish. I read the statewide total for every attorney general and governor election from 1954 through 2026. Where two official publications disagree on a figure, I've said which one I used and why: the 1956 Freeman total above, and 1998, where the Secretary of State's 1998 election book (Ventura 773,403, Coleman 716,880, Humphrey 587,060), which I used, differs by 310 to 470 votes for each of the three leading candidates from the 2011–2012 Manual's history table. The 1954, 1956 and 1958 summary pages don't print party labels; the parties come from the county tables in the same manuals. The 2026 figures are the unofficial count and can move before the State Canvassing Board certifies. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.