Picture a married couple. The house they live in is worth $400,000, and so is the lake cabin up north. Both names on both deeds. One checking account, both names on the signature card.
She's got a credit card in her name alone. It went bad, and whoever holds it now has a $20,000 judgment against her. Nobody's suing him, and in Minnesota nobody gets to: § 519.05 says "A spouse is not liable to a creditor for any debts of the other spouse." Since October 1, 2024, that sentence has stood without the old exception for necessary medical bills and household supplies. That's one Minnesota got right. What it hasn't fixed is what the card company can take from her share of what they own together.
Put them in Michigan, Pennsylvania or Florida, holding both places as tenants by the entirety, and the judgment can't reach either one. In Florida the checking account is presumed to be out of reach too, unless the account paperwork says it isn't. In Minnesota, the house comes out fine. The cabin doesn't.
The difference is an old common-law way for married couples to own property, called tenancy by the entirety. Minnesota threw it out before it was a state.
Minnesota gives you three ways to own land. Being married isn't one of them.
Here's the whole menu, § 500.19, subdivision 1:
"Estates, in respect to the number and connection of their owners, are divided into estates in severalty, in joint tenancy, and in common; the nature and properties of which, respectively, shall continue to be such as are now established by law, except so far as the same may be modified by the provisions of this chapter."
That leaves two ways to share: joint tenancy and tenancy in common. Subdivision 2 picks the default: a grant to two or more people creates a tenancy in common "unless expressly declared to be in joint tenancy." Married or not, two people on one Minnesota deed are one of those two things.
I went hunting for the missing fourth estate in the 2026 text of chapters 500, 507, 510 and 519. The word "entirety" shows up exactly once, in a line about revoking a transfer-on-death deed "in its entirety." So close. That's four chapters, not the whole book, but they're the ones on estates in real property, recording conveyances, the homestead exemption and married persons.
The Minnesota Supreme Court didn't need four chapters. In 1968 it needed one sentence: "in this state the estate of tenancy by the entirety, with its indestructible survivorship, is not recognized."
What does the card company get? Section 548.09:
"From the time of docketing the judgment is a lien, in the amount unpaid, upon all real property in the county then or thereafter owned by the judgment debtor"
And "The judgment survives, and the lien continues, for ten years after its entry." The card company dockets it in the county where the cabin sits, and it's a lien on her interest in the cabin until ten years after the judgment was entered. (If the cabin is registered land, the judgment isn't a lien on it until it's also recorded under the registered-land statutes. That's paperwork, not protection.) I've written about what a ten-year Minnesota judgment does before. A lake place is a new way to feel it.
The house is a different story, thanks to the homestead exemption. Section 510.01 makes "The house owned and occupied by a debtor as the debtor's dwelling place" exempt "from seizure or sale under legal process on account of any debt not lawfully charged thereon in writing," with exceptions that include debts for work or materials that went into the house. Section 510.02 caps it:
"The exemption per homestead, whether the exemption is claimed by one or more debtors, may not exceed $540,000 or, if the homestead is used primarily for agricultural purposes, $1,350,000"
That figure moved from $510,000 to $540,000 on July 1, 2026, per the Commerce Department's adjustment table. A $400,000 house sits comfortably under it, so a card judgment against one spouse gets nothing. The cap has its own history, and I've told it.
The states that leave the debt with the spouse who ran it up
Michigan did it in one sentence, in 2004:
"Property described in section 1 of 1927 PA 212, MCL 557.151, or real property, held jointly by a husband and wife as a tenancy by the entirety is exempt from execution under a judgment entered against only 1 spouse."
The section it points to covers bonds, stock certificates, mortgages, promissory notes and "other evidences of indebtedness" payable to a married couple. So the shield runs past the front door to any real property the couple holds that way, the cabin included, plus the paper. (The statute still says "husband and wife". Michigan hasn't gotten around to that.)
Pennsylvania does it through its courts. The lead opinion in a 1976 decision of its Supreme Court said that "property owned by tenants by the entireties is not subject to the debts of either spouse, and they may alien it without infringing upon the rights of their individual creditors." In 1988 its Superior Court, an intermediate appeals court, said that a judgment against the husband alone didn't even become a lien on the real estate he and his wife owned by the entireties: "A husband and wife do not own separate interests in entireties property which can be reached by their individual creditors." In Minnesota, the lien is the first thing the creditor gets.
Florida does both, statute and Supreme Court, and it's the one that got me. Florida's default rule reads a lot like ours: a conveyance to two or more people creates a tenancy in common unless it says survivorship. Then § 689.15 adds seven words that Minnesota's rule doesn't have: "except in cases of estates by entirety". Seven words. And § 689.11 lets the spouse who holds title create the estate just by "Conveying to both spouses."
In 2001 the Florida Supreme Court spelled out what the estate buys: "when property is held as a tenancy by the entireties, only the creditors of both the husband and wife, jointly, may attach the tenancy by the entireties property; the property is not divisible on behalf of one spouse alone, and therefore it cannot be reached to satisfy the obligation of only one spouse."
Then Florida carried it to the bank. Section 655.79(1):
"Any deposit or account made in the name of two persons who are husband and wife shall be considered a tenancy by the entirety unless otherwise specified in writing."
The same 2001 decision held that when the signature card on a married couple's joint account doesn't expressly disclaim it, and the account otherwise meets the old requirements for the estate, the account is presumed to be held by the entireties, and the burden shifts to the creditor to prove it isn't. The court carved out the bank that holds the deposits. Everyone else, her card company included, has to get past that presumption to touch the couple's checking.
Minnesota's rule on who owns a joint account, § 524.6-203(a), says it belongs to the parties "in proportion to the net contributions by each to the sums on deposit, unless there is clear and convincing evidence of a different intent." The word "married" isn't in it.
Other states draw a tighter circle. Illinois allows the estate only for property "maintained or intended for maintenance as a homestead", and its statute says that property "shall not be liable to be sold upon judgment entered on or after October 1, 1990 against only one of the tenants," unless it was moved into the estate solely to dodge debts the owner already had and couldn't pay. Income from it can still be garnished. Massachusetts shields one spouse's interest from that spouse's creditor "so long as such property is the principal residence of the nondebtor spouse", and both spouses stay on the hook for necessaries. Virginia lets spouses hold real or personal property this way "for as long as they are married", and gives entireties property moved into their trusts "the same immunity from the claims of their separate creditors as it would if it had remained a tenancy by the entirety," so long as they stay married and the property stays theirs in the trust.
How many states is that? You may have read "about half". I count only what I can read in a state's own statute or its high court's own words. That's at least nine that recognize the estate: Michigan, Pennsylvania, Florida, Illinois, Massachusetts, Virginia, Wyoming, North Carolina and Missouri. In six of them, the text I read shields it from one spouse's creditor. Ohio went Minnesota's way in 1985: entireties deeds recorded before the change stay good, and the deed its statute now describes for spouses creates a "survivorship tenancy" instead.
| State | How the estate arises | What one spouse's judgment creditor can reach |
|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | It doesn't. Severalty, joint tenancy or in common only (§ 500.19, subd. 1) | A lien on the debtor's interest in real property in the county, for ten years (§ 548.09). The homestead is exempt up to $540,000 (§ 510.02) |
| Michigan | Real property and personal property held by spouses as tenants by the entirety; notes, bonds and stock payable to spouses (MCL 557.71, 557.151) | Exempt from execution on a judgment against only one spouse (MCL 600.6023a) |
| Pennsylvania | Common law, stated in a 1976 Supreme Court opinion | "not subject to the debts of either spouse" (1976); not even a lien (1988) |
| Florida | Conveyance to both spouses (§ 689.11); spouses' joint deposit accounts by statute (§ 655.79) | Can't be reached for one spouse's debt; "only the creditors of both the husband and wife, jointly, may attach" it (2001) |
| Illinois | Homestead only (765 ILCS 1005/1 and 1005/1c) | Can't be sold on a judgment against one tenant entered on or after Oct. 1, 1990, except a debt-dodging transfer; income can be garnished (735 ILCS 5/12-112) |
| Massachusetts | Recognized by statute (c. 209, § 1) | Shielded while it's the nondebtor spouse's principal residence; necessaries excepted |
| Virginia | Real or personal property, "for as long as they are married" (§ 55.1-136) | Immunity from separate creditors, carried into the spouses' trusts |
| Wyoming, North Carolina, Missouri | Recognized by statute (W.S. 34-1-140; G.S. 41-56; RSMo 442.025) | Not addressed in the text I read |
So what does the card company get from this couple?
The $400,000 house. Minnesota: nothing for the card company, because $400,000 is under the $540,000 homestead line. Michigan, Pennsylvania, Florida, Illinois and Massachusetts: nothing, under their entireties rules. On the family home, Minnesota keeps up with every one of them.
The $400,000 cabin. Michigan, Pennsylvania and Florida, held by the entireties: nothing. Illinois and Massachusetts don't help here; their shields stop at the home. Minnesota: the cabin isn't her dwelling place, so the homestead exemption doesn't touch it, and the judgment is a lien on her interest for ten years. Up to ten summers at the lake with a lien on her share.
A bigger house. Make it $700,000, no mortgage. In Minnesota the exemption stops at $540,000, so $160,000 of that house is outside it. And it's per homestead, "whether the exemption is claimed by one or more debtors". Two spouses share one $540,000. Michigan's statute and the Pennsylvania and Florida passages I read don't put a dollar figure on the entireties shield.
The checking account. Florida presumes the couple's joint account is entireties property unless the paperwork says otherwise. Minnesota's ownership statute divides a joint account by who put the money in, and its text never mentions marriage. What a Minnesota bank levy does to a checking account in the first place is another piece.
Give Minnesota its due
Minnesota's homestead exemption protects "a debtor". Single. Divorced. Widowed. Two people who never married. Entireties protects married couples and nobody else, and in Virginia it lasts "for as long as they are married." A single nurse in Duluth with a $400,000 house gets nothing from Michigan's rule. She gets all of Minnesota's.
And entireties cuts both ways. Florida's own Supreme Court says the creditors of both spouses, jointly, can attach it. Put the card in both names, or co-sign, and the shield's gone as to that creditor. Minnesota's homestead exemption holds against "any debt not lawfully charged thereon in writing," joint or not, up to $540,000, with only the exceptions chapter 510 lists. On the family home, I'd take Minnesota's rule any day.
The trouble is everything that isn't the family home.
Blame it on 1851
In 1890 the Minnesota Supreme Court walked through the history. The reason for the old rule, the court said, quoting Blackstone, was "husband and wife being considered as one person in law". The Revised Statutes of 1851, written when Minnesota was still a territory, divided estates into severalty, joint tenancy and tenancy in common, in the same sentence that's in § 500.19 today, and the court read that sentence alone to leave no room for an estate by the entirety. The 1851 law did carve out conveyances "to husband and wife" from the tenancy-in-common default. In the 1866 revision the Legislature struck those words. Another chapter of that same revision, the court said, ended the unity of husband and wife "so far as related to rights of property," and after it a wife could take and hold property, with some limits, "as though she were sole." Keeping the estate after that, in the court's words, "would have been inconsistent". So, the court held, spouses take like any other two people: as tenants in common unless the deed says joint tenancy.
Getting rid of the one-person-in-law idea was the right call. The creditor protection went out with the bathwater, and nobody went back for it. The sentence the territorial legislature wrote in 1851 is the sentence in our statute book 175 years later, and every card issuer that lends to one spouse in this state gets the benefit.
Michigan has the estate, and in 2004 it wrote the creditor rule into one plain sentence. Florida wrote the bank account into one. Minnesota's Legislature has found time to rewrite the homestead cap and index it. Neither sentence is in § 500.19, chapter 510 or § 524.6-203.
What we can do
Add the estate to § 500.19, subdivision 1. One phrase: estates in severalty, in joint tenancy, in common, and by the entirety. Then a new subdivision letting spouses take that way, written for spouses, not "husband and wife".
Borrow Michigan's creditor sentence. Put it in chapter 550 next to the other exemptions: property held by spouses as tenants by the entirety "is exempt from execution under a judgment entered against only 1 spouse." No dollar figure, because one spouse's card debt was never the other spouse's to begin with.
Borrow Florida's account sentence. Add it to § 524.6-203: an account in the names of two spouses "shall be considered a tenancy by the entirety unless otherwise specified in writing."
Borrow Illinois's guardrail. No protection for property moved into the estate "with the sole intent to avoid the payment of debts existing at the time of the transfer beyond the transferor's ability to pay those debts as they become due." And keep Florida's rule that the creditors of both spouses, jointly, can still reach it.
Keep the homestead exemption for everybody. The estate goes on top of it, not in place of it. The single nurse in Duluth keeps every dollar she has today.
Michigan tells the card company the lake place is exempt from a judgment against only the spouse who signed for the card. Minnesota hands it a lien on her share of it.
First the facts. Then the fix.
Sources
Minnesota: Minn. Stat. §§ 500.19, 510.01, 510.02, 519.05, 524.6-203 and 548.09, and the full text of chapters 500, 507, 510 and 519, 2026 editions, read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19 and 21, 2026; Laws 2024, chapter 114, article 3, section 83 ("This section is effective October 1, 2024."); the Revisor's session-law index, which lists 1851 as the Second Territorial Legislature and 1858 as the First Legislature. Homestead figure: Minnesota Department of Commerce, Historic Adjustments table (rev. June 25, 2026), $510,000 effective July 1, 2024 and $540,000 effective July 1, 2026.
Other states: Mich. Comp. Laws §§ 600.6023a, 557.71 and 557.151 (legislature.mi.gov); Fla. Stat. §§ 655.79, 689.11 and 689.15 (leg.state.fl.us); 735 ILCS 5/12-112 and 765 ILCS 1005/1 and 1005/1c (ilga.gov); Mass. Gen. Laws c. 209, § 1 (malegislature.gov); Va. Code § 55.1-136 (law.lis.virginia.gov); Wyo. Stat. § 34-1-140 (wyoleg.gov); N.C. Gen. Stat. § 41-56 (ncleg.gov); Mo. Rev. Stat. § 442.025 (revisor.mo.gov); Ohio Rev. Code § 5302.21 (codes.ohio.gov). All read November 19, 2026, except 765 ILCS 1005/1, read November 21, 2026.
Court decisions, described by court and year: Minnesota Supreme Court (1890) on the 1851 and 1866 statutes; Minnesota Supreme Court (1968) on joint-tenancy severance; Pennsylvania Supreme Court (1976); Pennsylvania Superior Court (1988); Florida Supreme Court (2001) on entireties property and spouses' bank accounts. Opinion text read from the Caselaw Access Project's published reports.
The worked examples are my arithmetic on those texts.
What I could not establish. The national count: "about half the states" is a figure I could not tie to primary sources, so I counted only the nine states whose own statute or high court I read; Indiana, New York, Hawaii and others are reported to recognize the estate and are not in my count. Pennsylvania's statute text was not available to me; its rule above is from its courts. Wyoming, North Carolina and Missouri recognize the estate in the text I read, but those sections don't say what one spouse's creditor can reach. I did not establish how a Minnesota creditor can enforce a judgment lien against one co-owner's interest in a cabin, so I say lien and stop there; nor how a Minnesota garnishment of a married couple's joint account is applied in practice, beyond the ownership rule in § 524.6-203. My search for the estate in Minnesota law covered four full chapters, not the entire statute book. I did not establish whether any bill to create the estate has been introduced in the Minnesota Legislature. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.