Say you've got $3,000 in checking. Fifteen hundred of it is last Friday's paycheck. The other $1,500 is what's left from the month before. A debt buyer is sitting on a $20,000 judgment from an old credit card, and this week it went after your bank.
In Minnesota, the bank can freeze all $3,000. Not just the old money. All of it, paycheck included. Then it mails you a packet, and the clock starts.
In New York, on the same facts, the freeze is void. Nobody has to fill out anything.
How much can a Minnesota bank freeze?
All of it, up to 110 percent of the judgment. The levy statute is § 550.143. Subdivision 3 tells the bank what to do once the writ and the paperwork land:
"the financial institution shall retain as much of the amount due under section 550.04 as the financial institution has on deposit owing to the judgment debtor, but not more than 110 percent of the amount remaining due on the judgment."
A hundred and ten percent of $20,000 is $22,000. You have $3,000. The bank holds the $3,000.
So what does Minnesota protect automatically? I went looking for the number. There isn't one. I read all 33 subdivisions of § 550.37, the statute that lists what a creditor can't take. Outside bankruptcy, and apart from retirement accounts and health savings accounts (subds. 24 and 26), three of them reach money sitting in an ordinary bank account, and all three are tracing rules. The exempt part of a paycheck stays exempt "for 20 days after deposit in any financial institution" (subd. 13). Need-based public assistance stays exempt "for 60 days after deposit" (subd. 14). Certain other exempt money, like insurance proceeds and employee-benefit payments, stays exempt in the bank "if the funds are traceable to their exempt source" (subd. 20). All three carry the same sentence: "The burden of establishing that funds are exempt rests upon the debtor."
Protected, then. If you can prove it.
There's exactly one flat dollar figure in the whole statute for "funds in a bank account". Subdivision 28, all of it:
"In a bankruptcy, a debtor may exempt any property, including funds in a bank account, up to $1,650 in value."
Three words up front, "In a bankruptcy," and the only bank-account number in Minnesota law vanishes the minute you're fighting a levy instead of filing a petition. Outside bankruptcy, the number is zero. I've written about how thin that wild card is, and about the rest of that exemption list.
Fourteen days and a stack of bank statements
So how do you get your paycheck back? You ask for it. On paper. Fast.
Within two business days of getting the writ, the bank must send you notice. The Legislature wrote the notice into the statute, § 571.912 for a garnishment and § 550.143, subd. 3a for a levy. The top of it says "Money in Your Account Has Been Frozen". Then:
"The amount being held is frozen for 14 days from the date of this notice."
And then the catch:
"BUT, if you want the bank to unfreeze your money, you must follow the instructions and return the exemption form with copies of your bank statements from the last 60 days."
The rule behind the form is § 550.143, subd. 4. You sign under penalty of perjury and get one copy to the bank and one to the creditor's lawyer "within 14 days of the date postmarked on the correspondence mailed to the debtor containing the exemption notices." And "The judgment debtor is also required to include copies of bank statements for the prior 60 days with the exemption notice delivered to the attorney for the judgment creditor."
Sixty days of your bank statements, mailed to the debt buyer's lawyer. Every grocery run, in the hands of the people collecting from you. That's the price of asking for your own paycheck back.
Miss the window and "the funds remain subject to the execution levy and shall be remitted to the sheriff within six business days." Make the window and the money you claimed as exempt comes back "upon the expiration of six business days after the date postmarked on the envelope containing the executed exemption notice mailed to the financial institution," "unless within that time the judgment creditor interposes an objection to the exemption." If the creditor objects, the court administrator schedules a hearing five to seven business days out, and the bank keeps sitting on the money "until otherwise ordered by the court or upon mutual agreement of the parties."
Rent's due on the first either way.
How much of the paycheck comes back
The exemption form in § 571.912, subd. 3 puts the paycheck rule in plain words:
"For wages that were deposited in your account within the last 20 days, the amount protected is whichever is more:"
"(i) 75% of your wages or more (after taxes are taken out), or"
"(ii) The current minimum wage times 40 per week."
Run the numbers. Seventy-five percent of a $1,500 net paycheck is $1,125. Minnesota's minimum wage in 2026 is $11.41 an hour, so 40 times that is $456.40 a week, or $912.80 for a two-week check. The bigger number wins: at least $1,125 comes back, if you claimed it in time and nobody objected.
That leaves last month's $1,500, and it isn't wages anymore, as far as the statute cares. It's past the 20 days. It goes to the debt buyer.
Do everything right, with 60 days of statements in the envelope, and the best case is at least $1,125 of $3,000 back, after a week or more without it. The worst case is zero.
This is the line that gets me. The same subdivision 13 that sets the 20-day rule also says, about wages still at the employer: "The disposable earnings exempt from garnishment are exempt as a matter of right, whether claimed or not by the person to whom due." Whether claimed or not. Then the paycheck lands in checking, and suddenly the burden's on you. The money didn't change. Its address did.
What New York did instead
New York flipped it. The first sentence of CPLR 5222(i) says a restraining notice (New York's bank freeze) "shall not apply to an amount equal to or less than the greater of two hundred forty times the federal minimum hourly wage prescribed in the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 or two hundred forty times the state minimum hourly wage prescribed in section six hundred fifty-two of the labor law".
And if the whole account is small enough:
"Where a judgment debtor's account contains an amount equal to or less than ninety percent of the greater of two hundred forty times the federal minimum hourly wage prescribed in the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 or two hundred forty times the state minimum hourly wage prescribed in section six hundred fifty-two of the labor law as in effect at the time the earnings are payable (as published on the websites of the United States department of labor and the state department of labor), the account shall not be restrained and the restraining notice shall be deemed void, except as to those funds that a court determines to be unnecessary for the reasonable requirements of the judgment debtor and his or her dependents."
The arithmetic for 2026: New York's Labor Law § 652 sets the minimum wage at $17.00 in New York City and Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester counties, and $16.00 everywhere else in the state.
- Everywhere outside New York City, Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester: 240 × $16.00 = $3,840. Ninety percent of that is $3,456.
- New York City, Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester: 240 × $17.00 = $4,080. Ninety percent of that is $3,672.
Our $3,000 is under both lines. The restraining notice is void. The bank doesn't freeze it. The debtor doesn't mail anything. On a card judgment, the way back in is a court deciding the money is "unnecessary for the reasonable requirements" of the debtor and the family.
And if a bank can't find where you work? New York's Department of Financial Services told banks on November 4, 2026 that "the banking institution may use the highest minimum wage in effect in the State at the time of such calculation." Tie goes to the account holder.
New York's statute pegs the protected amount at "seventeen hundred forty dollars on July twenty-fourth, two thousand nine," rising "in tandem with the minimum wage." That's at least seventeen years of New York banks managing to leave a paycheck alone.
Bigger accounts get a claim process, and it's gentler than ours. The New Yorker gets 20 days to send the claim form, not 14, and the bank releases the money eight days after the postmark on the claim form unless the creditor objects. The form lists "Income earned in the last 60 days (90% of which is exempt)" as a reason, which is three times Minnesota's 20-day window at a higher percentage. And it asks for records only if you have them: "If you have any documents, such as an award letter, an annual statement from your pension, paystubs, copies of checks or bank records showing the last two months of account activity, include copies of the documents with this form. Your account may be released more quickly." In New York the records are an invitation. In Minnesota they're a requirement. And when exempt payments like Social Security or a pension were direct-deposited in the 45 days before the bank was served, a separate floor applies: $2,500 in the statute, indexed by the Department of Financial Services to $3,425 for cases begun on or after April 1, 2024.
California and Massachusetts don't make you ask
In California, the Judicial Council's current exemption form, revised July 20, 2026, lists "Deposit account, generally (exemption without claim; amount per judgment debtor, section 704.220(a) & (e))" at $2,325, effective July 1, 2026 and adjusted every year. The form adds that this "exemption does not preclude or reduce other exemptions for deposit accounts." So the first $2,325 is exempt without anyone filing a thing, and the debtor can still claim more.
Massachusetts just writes the number down. Chapter 246, § 28A:
"Twenty-five hundred dollars of any natural person in an account in a trust company, savings bank, cooperative bank, credit union, national banking association or other banking institution doing business in the commonwealth shall be exempt from attachment by trustee process."
And the bank's instruction: "Upon service of a trustee summons, the trustee shall answer as subject to attachment only so much money of the defendant that exceeds $2,500." The general execution exemption in chapter 235, § 34, clause Fifteenth, says the same $2,500 for "cash or savings or other deposits in a banking or investment institution".
Delaware goes about as far as a statute can go. Its attachment chapter says banks "shall not be subject to the operations of the attachment laws of this State", except for attaching the wages of the bank's own employees (10 Del. C. § 3502(b)). Whether a Delaware creditor can reach a deposit some other way is a separate question, so Delaware stays out of the table.
The same $3,000, four ways
| State | Automatic floor | What the debtor must do | What's left of $3,000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | None outside bankruptcy (§ 550.37); bank holds up to 110% of the judgment (§ 550.143, subd. 3) | Mail the signed form to the bank and the creditor's lawyer within 14 days, with 60 days of bank statements; wait at least six business days; a hearing if the creditor objects | $0 without a claim. With a timely claim, at least $1,125 (75% of the paycheck) |
| New York | Restraint doesn't reach 240 × the minimum wage ($3,840 in most of the state, $4,080 in New York City, Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester); void at or under 90% of that ($3,456 / $3,672) (CPLR 5222(i)) | Nothing | $3,000 |
| California | $2,325, "exemption without claim" (Judicial Council form EJ-156) | Nothing for the $2,325; a claim for anything more | At least $2,325 |
| Massachusetts | $2,500 (c. 246, § 28A; c. 235, § 34, cl. Fifteenth) | Nothing for the $2,500 | At least $2,500 |
The Minnesotan who does everything right can still end up $1,875 behind the New Yorker who did nothing.
Give Minnesota its due
Minnesota gets some of this right. Missing paperwork doesn't waive your exemption: under § 550.143, subd. 4, "Failure of the judgment debtor to deliver the executed exemption notice or copies of the required bank statements for the prior 60 days does not constitute a waiver of any claimed right to an exemption." The notice itself says that if the bank pays the creditor and the money was protected, "you can still get it back from the creditor later." The 20-day wage rule is real protection, and it reaches the bank too: it "also applies to any contractual setoff or security interest asserted by a financial institution in which the earnings are deposited by the individual", so your own bank can't grab exempt wages to cover what you owe it. Need-based aid like SNAP, MFIP and SSI is protected for 60 days after deposit. For a low earner, the form's floor of the minimum wage times 40 a week protects a weekly check of $456.40 or less in full. And bad faith has a price: if a court finds the creditor "disregarded the claim of exemption in bad faith, the judgment debtor shall be awarded costs, reasonable attorney fees, actual damages, and an amount not to exceed $100."
It's a real system. It's just built backward: freeze everything first, then make the person with the frozen account prove the rest.
Who does the system look after first?
Not the account holder. Subdivision 20 of § 550.37: "No bank or other financial institution shall be liable for damages for complying with process duly issued out of any court for the collection of a debt even if the funds affected by the process are subsequently determined to have been exempt." The bank that freezes your exempt paycheck is covered. Your paycheck isn't.
The Legislature had this form on the table in 2024. Section 103 of the 2024 commerce act, Laws 2024, chapter 114, article 3, told the attorney general to review the garnishment notices, § 571.912 included, recommend plain-language revisions, and "obtain approval from affected business and consumer groups". The list started with the Minnesota Creditors' Rights Association, the Great Lakes Credit and Collections Association, the Minnesota Bankers' Association, the Minnesota Credit Union Network and BankIn Minnesota. Legal aid and consumer groups came after.
The current form carries a 2025 amendment, and it reads more plainly than most statutes. It still freezes everything, still gives you 14 days, and still asks for 60 days of bank statements. Same deal.
For 2024, the Campaign Finance Board's files show those first five groups reporting a combined $653,000 in lobbying spending. Those are totals across every subject each group lobbied on. The files don't say a dollar of it went to bank-account exemptions, and I'm not saying it either.
What we can do
Put a number in § 550.37, and make it automatic. Add a subdivision that protects a fixed amount in every natural person's deposit account, and borrow Minnesota's own words from subdivision 13: exempt "as a matter of right, whether claimed or not". We wrote that phrase already. It just never followed the paycheck to the bank. For the amount, borrow New York's formula and tie it to Minnesota's minimum wage in § 177.24. At $11.41 that's 240 × $11.41 = $2,738.40, and it rises on its own when the wage does: the state's minimum wage goes to $11.87 on January 1, 2027, which makes it $2,848.80. That's less than New York protects, because our minimum wage is lower. If the Legislature wants a flat figure, Massachusetts uses $2,500, and § 550.37, subd. 4a already indexes every dollar amount in the section except those in subdivisions 5 and 7.
Tell the bank to hold only the excess. Amend § 550.143, subd. 3, and the matching garnishment provisions in chapter 571, with the Massachusetts sentence: the bank answers "only so much money of the defendant that exceeds" the protected amount. Then take New York's second step. When the whole account is at or under 90 percent of the floor, the freeze is void and the bank does nothing. On the Minnesota formula that's $2,464.56 today.
Stop asking for 60 days of statements up front. For the protected amount, there's nothing to prove. For anything above it, make records optional, the way New York does, and give people 20 days instead of 14.
Stretch the wage window. New York's claim form lists income earned in the last 60 days as 90 percent exempt. Minnesota's stops at 20.
Under that fix, our Minnesotan with $3,000 would keep $2,738.40 without lifting a finger, and could claim the other $261.60 as wages. Today that same Minnesotan keeps nothing unless the envelope goes out within 14 days.
Minnesota already wrote a number for money in an ordinary bank account. It just put "In a bankruptcy" in front of it.
First the facts. Then the fix.
Sources
Minnesota: Minn. Stat. § 550.37, subds. 4a, 13, 14, 20, 24, 26 and 28; § 550.143, subds. 3, 3a, 4, 5, 6 and 10; § 571.912, subds. 1 and 3 (2026 editions), read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19, 2026; § 177.24 (2026 edition), read there November 6, 2026. Laws 2024, ch. 114, art. 3, § 103, from the Revisor's session-law page. Minimum wage: Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry, "Minimum wage in Minnesota", $11.41 as of January 1, 2026 and $11.87 as of January 1, 2027. Lobbying: Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, Principal Expenditures 2009–Present download, report year 2024, retrieved November 6, 2026.
New York: N.Y. CPLR 5205(d)(2) and (l), 5222(i) and 5222-a(b), (c); N.Y. Labor Law § 652(1-a), from the New York Legislature's public laws site (current through 2026 Chapters 1–375). New York State Department of Financial Services, "Amount Exempt from Judgments" ($3,425, effective April 1, 2024) and industry letter of November 4, 2026, "The Exempt Income Protection Act and Annual Minimum Wage Increases", dfs.ny.gov.
California: Judicial Council of California, form EJ-156, "Current Dollar Amounts of Exemptions From Enforcement of Judgments", Rev. July 20, 2026, p. 2, courts.ca.gov.
Massachusetts: Mass. Gen. Laws c. 246, § 28A and c. 235, § 34, cl. Fifteenth (malegislature.gov). Delaware: 10 Del. C. § 3502(b) (delcode.delaware.gov). All read November 19, 2026. The table is my application of those texts to the stated facts: a single worker with no public benefits, $3,000 in checking of which $1,500 is a net paycheck deposited within 20 days, and a $20,000 judgment.
What I could not establish. I could not open the text of California's Code of Civil Procedure §§ 704.220 and 704.070 on the Legislature's site; the $2,325 figure and the "exemption without claim" wording come from the courts' current exemption form, and I have not described California's rules for wages deposited in an account. Whether Massachusetts' wage exemption follows wages into a bank account, and whether a Delaware creditor can reach a deposit by execution or another process outside the attachment chapter, are questions I did not resolve. Minnesota's form protects "75% of your wages or more"; a lower-paid worker may be able to protect more of a paycheck than the table shows, and I have not run the garnishment tiers for this example. How Minnesota treats money in a joint account that belongs to someone who doesn't owe the debt is outside this piece. I did not search the Legislature's bill record for a proposal to add a bank-account floor. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.