A seller tells you something it knows isn't true, and that's how it gets $2,000 out of you. You sue. You win. Now, what does the check say?

In Massachusetts, a judge who finds the seller knew has to award at least double and can award triple: $4,000 to $6,000, unless the seller made a reasonable settlement offer you turned down. In Washington, a judge can make it $6,000. In Texas, a jury or judge can make it $6,000 and add damages for mental anguish. In Minnesota, the consumer-fraud statute gives you back your $2,000 and pays your lawyer.

That's the deal Minnesota offers a seller who lies on purpose. Get caught, give the money back. Keep everybody else's, unless the State comes calling. Some business model.

What Minnesota's statute actually says

The ban is broad, and it's good. Section 325F.69, subd. 1:

"The act, use, or employment by any person of any fraud, unfair or unconscionable practice, false pretense, false promise, misrepresentation, misleading statement or deceptive practice, with the intent that others rely thereon in connection with the sale of any merchandise, whether or not any person has in fact been misled, deceived, or damaged thereby, is enjoinable as provided in section 325F.70."

In 2023 the Legislature added subdivision 8, which says an unfair or unconscionable practice is one that "(1) offends public policy as established by the statutes, rules, or common law of Minnesota; (2) is unethical, oppressive, or unscrupulous; or (3) is substantially injurious to consumers."

Now what you get. Here's § 325F.70, subd. 3(a), in full:

"(a) In addition to the remedies otherwise provided by law, a consumer injured by a violation of sections 325F.68 to 325F.70, in connection with a sale of merchandise for personal, family, household, or agricultural purposes, may bring a civil action and recover damages, together with costs and disbursements, including costs of investigation and reasonable attorney fees, and receive other equitable relief as determined by the court. An action brought under this section benefits the public."

Two words carry the payout: "recover damages". Damages means what you lost. Lose $2,000, get $2,000. The text has no minimum and no multiplier. If the harm is real but hard to put a dollar on, the statute doesn't promise you a nickel for it.

The older private remedy, § 8.31, subd. 3a, covers the laws referred to in § 8.31, subd. 1, the consumer-fraud act included. Same payout: "recover damages, together with costs and disbursements, including costs of investigation and reasonable attorney's fees".

The Deceptive Trade Practices Act's own remedy section pays less than that. Under § 325D.45, subd. 1, "A person likely to be damaged by a deceptive trade practice of another may be granted an injunction against it". That's the remedy in that section: an order to stop. The court can award attorney fees to the person who complained only if the other side "willfully engaged in the trade practice knowing it to be deceptive." The section awards no damages.

What about the State? Under § 8.31, subd. 3, the Attorney General can sue for "a civil penalty, in an amount to be determined by the court, not in excess of $25,000." And: "All sums recovered by the attorney general under this section shall be deposited in the general fund." The State sued under the consumer-fraud, deceptive-trade and false-advertising laws in 2009, and ten days later a debt-collection arbitration outfit was barred from taking new consumer cases (the piece on the Forum). Those laws have teeth when the State bites. But the penalty is the State's money. It doesn't go to the person who got cheated.

There's one add-on. When the conduct is perpetrated against a senior citizen, defined as 62 or older, or a disabled person, § 325F.71, subd. 2(a) makes the seller liable for "an additional civil penalty not to exceed $10,000 for each violation," if at least one of the aggravating factors the statute lists is present. It's a penalty. The section's private remedy, subd. 4, is for "damages".

2023: the Legislature fixed the door

In 2000, the Minnesota Supreme Court read a requirement into the private remedy that the Legislature never wrote. The court held that § 8.31, subd. 3a "applies only to those claimants who demonstrate that their cause of action benefits the public." The man in that case had bought a restaurant on misrepresentations about its profits. The trial court found he'd been defrauded and gave him $25,000 in common-law fraud damages. He asked for $60,920.55 in costs and attorney fees under the statute. He got none of it. He'd been lied to one-on-one, and in the court's words, "enforcement has no public benefit".

So for 23 years, a Minnesotan cheated in a single deal could win and still lose, because the lawyer's bill could swallow the recovery. Dissenting on that point, one justice wrote that the Legislature "could have easily done so" if it had wanted that limit. "Whether for good or for ill, by the plain words of the statute, it did not."

In 2023 the Legislature answered. Laws 2023, ch. 52, art. 19, § 15, part of S.F. 2909, added the new subdivision 3 to § 325F.70, a private remedy for consumers whose first paragraph ends with nine words: "An action brought under this section benefits the public." It took effect August 1, 2023, and "applies to causes of action commenced on or after that date."

That's the Legislature answering a Supreme Court decision in plain words, on the face of the statute. It deserves the credit.

The fix has edges. The word "consumer" means "a natural person or family farmer". The sale has to be of merchandise "for personal, family, household, or agricultural purposes". And the nine words went into § 325F.70. They didn't go into § 8.31, subd. 3a, the private remedy for the other laws § 8.31, subd. 1 refers to.

Here's the part that got me. Put the 2023 damages clause next to § 8.31's: "recover damages, together with costs and disbursements, including costs of investigation and reasonable attorney fees". The only difference I can find is the apostrophe in "attorney's". The Legislature fixed who gets through the door. It copied the payout.

What a lie costs somewhere else

Massachusetts. Chapter 93A, § 9(3):

"recovery shall be in the amount of actual damages or twenty-five dollars, whichever is greater; or up to three but not less than two times such amount if the court finds that the use or employment of the act or practice was a willful or knowing violation of said section two or that the refusal to grant relief upon demand was made in bad faith with knowledge or reason to know that the act or practice complained of violated said section two."

Three things Minnesota doesn't have, in one sentence. A floor, so a consumer who wins collects at least $25. A multiplier for knowing conduct. And a second trigger: a seller that gets a demand, knows or should know it's in the wrong, and stonewalls in bad faith faces the same double or triple. Section 9(4) piles on: the consumer "shall, in addition to other relief provided for by this section and irrespective of the amount in controversy, be awarded reasonable attorney's fees and costs incurred in connection with said action".

Massachusetts makes you work for it. Unless the claim is a counterclaim or cross-claim, or the seller doesn't maintain a place of business or doesn't keep assets in Massachusetts, "At least thirty days prior to the filing of any such action, a written demand for relief" has to go to the seller. If the seller answers within 30 days with a written settlement offer you turn down, and the court finds it was reasonable, your recovery is capped at what was offered. Fees after a rejected reasonable offer are out too.

Washington. RCW 19.86.090 lets an injured person sue "to recover the actual damages sustained by him or her" along with "the costs of the suit, including a reasonable attorney's fee." Then:

"In addition, the court may, in its discretion, increase the award of damages up to an amount not to exceed three times the actual damages sustained: PROVIDED, That such increased damage award for violation of RCW 19.86.020 may not exceed twenty-five thousand dollars"

Up to the judge, capped, and only for a person "injured in his or her business or property". On a $2,000 loss, the cap never comes into it.

Texas. Bus. & Com. Code § 17.50(b)(1): "If the trier of fact finds that the conduct of the defendant was committed knowingly, the consumer may also recover damages for mental anguish, as found by the trier of fact, and the trier of fact may award not more than three times the amount of economic damages". Subsection (d): "Each consumer who prevails shall be awarded court costs and reasonable and necessary attorneys' fees." Texas has its own hoops: written notice "at least 60 days before filing the suit" under § 17.505(a), and a deceptive-act claim has to rest on a practice on the statute's list that the consumer relied on.

Wisconsin's § 100.18 pays what Minnesota's statute pays. Section 100.18(11)(b)2: a person "shall recover such pecuniary loss, together with costs, including reasonable attorney fees". Double damages come only for a violation "of any injunction issued under this section", and under § 100.20(5) for a violation "of s. 100.70 or any order issued under this section", which takes in the general orders the department may issue forbidding unfair trade practices, § 100.20(2)(a).

Illinois lets the court "award actual economic damages or any other relief which the court deems proper" (815 ILCS 505/10a(a)). Its fee clause runs "to the prevailing party", which can be the business.

Same $2,000 charge, knowing conduct, consumer wins:

State Floor Multiplier $2,000 knowing charge, damages Who gets the fees
Minnesota (§ 325F.70, subd. 3; § 8.31, subd. 3a) None None $2,000 The injured consumer: costs, costs of investigation, reasonable attorney fees
Wisconsin (§ 100.18(11)(b)2) None Double only for violating an injunction (or, under § 100.20(5), § 100.70 or an order issued under § 100.20) $2,000 ($4,000 where the practice violates a § 100.20 order) The person suffering the loss: costs, including reasonable attorney fees
Illinois (815 ILCS 505/10a) None None written in the section $2,000 actual economic damages, plus "any other relief which the court deems proper" The prevailing party, either side, at the court's discretion
Washington (RCW 19.86.090) None Up to three times, at the court's discretion; increased award capped at $25,000 $2,000 to $6,000 The injured person: costs of the suit, including a reasonable attorney's fee
Texas (§ 17.50(b), (d)) None Up to three times economic damages for knowing conduct, plus mental anguish Up to $6,000, plus mental anguish Every consumer who prevails, mandatory
Massachusetts (c. 93A, § 9(3), (4)) $25 Two to three times for a willful or knowing violation, or a bad-faith refusal of a demand $4,000 to $6,000 The consumer who proves a violation, mandatory, "irrespective of the amount in controversy"

The floor and multiplier columns are each statute's text. The damages column is my arithmetic on it.

Give Minnesota its due

Minnesota gets some things right here. It pays the "costs of investigation", a phrase that isn't in the Massachusetts, Washington or Texas sections quoted above. Its text makes you send no demand letter and wait out no 30- or 60-day clock, and it has no tender rule a seller can use to cap your recovery with a lowball offer. And since August 1, 2023, the statute itself says a consumer's suit "benefits the public", the Legislature's answer to 23 years of making fraud victims prove it.

Wisconsin's § 100.18 pays the same one times the loss and says nothing about costs of investigation. Illinois can stick a consumer who loses with the seller's lawyer. Minnesota's fee language names only the injured consumer.

Why it's this way

The record shows what happened. It doesn't show why.

Twenty-three years after the 2000 decision, the Legislature answered it for consumers, in the 2023 omnibus bill "providing law for judiciary, public safety, crime," and a long list of other things, in an article headed "CIVIL LAW". That's where this fix lived: deep in an omnibus, under a heading in capital letters. The same section that wrote the nine words could have changed "recover damages". It didn't.

Meanwhile, the State's side of the ledger has a number, $25,000, and a destination, the general fund. The victim's side has no number at all. It has whatever the victim lost.

The other side's best case

Here's the best case for leaving it alone, in my words. Minnesota already pays the consumer's lawyer, and that's what gets a $2,000 case filed. A multiplier on top could turn every disputed sale into a threat letter, and the honest seller who made a mistake pays to settle. Massachusetts does wrap its multiplier in a demand letter and a tender cap.

That's a fair point about honest mistakes. It's no point at all about knowing ones. Massachusetts doesn't double the honest seller's bill. It doubles the bill of a seller a court finds acted willfully or knowingly. Fees make a small case possible. They don't make lying expensive. A seller that knows the worst outcome is giving back what it took, and only to the customers who sue, has already priced the risk. It comes out ahead on everyone who doesn't.

What we can do

Put a multiplier in § 325F.70, subd. 3(a). Borrow Massachusetts's sentence, "recovery shall be in the amount of actual damages or twenty-five dollars, whichever is greater; or up to three but not less than two times such amount if the court finds that the use or employment of the act or practice was a willful or knowing violation", and attach it to "recover damages". Massachusetts picked $25 for its floor. Minnesota can pick its own number.

Don't borrow the hoops. Leave out the 30-day demand and the tender cap.

Finish the 2023 job. Add the same nine words, "An action brought under this section benefits the public", to § 8.31, subd. 3a, so they cover every law § 8.31, subd. 1 refers to, not just the consumer-fraud act.

Say who gets the senior penalty. Section 325F.71 can make a seller whose conduct is perpetrated against a senior or a disabled person liable for up to $10,000 a violation. The statute should say plainly whether a court can award it to the person who was cheated.

In 2023 Minnesota wrote into law that a fraud victim's lawsuit benefits the public. It still pays that victim back to zero and not a dollar past it. In Massachusetts, a seller caught knowingly lying pays for the lie two or three times over. In Minnesota, the customer who wins gets a refund, plus costs and attorney fees. That isn't a punishment. It's a return policy.

First the facts. Then the fix.


Sources

Minnesota Statutes §§ 325F.69, subds. 1 and 8; 325F.70, subds. 1 and 3; 325F.71, subds. 1, 2 and 4; 325D.45, subds. 1–3; and 8.31, subds. 1, 3 and 3a (2026 editions), read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19, 2026, with each section's history line. Session law: Laws 2023, ch. 52 (S.F. 2909), art. 19, § 15, including its effective-date clause, from the Revisor's session-law page. The 2000 decision: Minnesota Supreme Court opinion of August 3, 2000, majority and dissents, read from the published opinion text.

Other states, each in the current text posted on its legislature's site: Mass. Gen. Laws c. 93A, § 9 (malegislature.gov); Rev. Code Wash. § 19.86.090 (app.leg.wa.gov); 815 ILCS 505/10a (ilga.gov); Tex. Bus. & Com. Code §§ 17.50 and 17.505 (tcss.legis.texas.gov); Wis. Stat. §§ 100.18 and 100.20(2) and (5) (2023-24 Wisconsin Statutes, published November 4, 2026; docs.legis.wisconsin.gov). All read November 19, 2026. The table's damages column is my arithmetic on a $2,000 loss under each statute's text.

The 2009 Forum case: see the sources in the piece on the Forum.

What I could not establish. I did not research how courts have applied the 2023 sentence "An action brought under this section benefits the public", or whether the 2000 public-benefit rule still governs § 8.31, subd. 3a claims under laws other than the consumer-fraud act. I did not determine whether a private plaintiff can collect the § 325F.71 senior and disabled penalty. Illinois's section names punitive damages only to limit them against vehicle dealers and retail-installment holders; what Illinois allows against other sellers is a matter of case law I did not pull, so the table's Illinois row reports only what the section's text says. This piece covers the consumer-fraud and deceptive-trade statutes; it does not cover common-law fraud or other routes to damages beyond the loss in any state. I did not search the bill record for any Minnesota proposal to add a multiplier. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.

Related research

Chosen by shared subject and shared statute, not by date.

Minnesota by the Numbers

Win a Credit Card Lawsuit in Washington and the Fee Clause Can Pay Your Lawyer. Win One in Minnesota and You Get $200.

A Capital One card agreement says that if the bank sues, you pay its court costs, expenses and attorney fees. Nowhere does it say who pays when the bank loses.…

Minnesota by the Numbers

Minnesota Has One General Service-Contract Statute. It Tells an Uninsured Seller to Print 'Full Faith and Credit of the Provider,' the State Guaranty Fund Excludes Even the Insured Version, and the Phrase 'Home Service Contract' Appears Nowhere in Minnesota Law.

Chapter 59B exempts service-contract sellers from state licensing and from every provision of the insurance code but one. Its definition of a protected buyer is…

Also turns on Minn. Stat. § 325F.69
Minnesota by the Numbers

Minnesota Made the Advertised Price the Price You Pay — Then Wrote Nine More Paragraphs Around It, and Left the Number Itself Alone

Since January 1, 2025, advertising a price that leaves out a mandatory fee has been a deceptive trade practice in Minnesota. The prohibition is one sentence. The…

← PreviousTenancy by the entirety106 of 114 in Minnesota by the NumbersNext →The couch and the car

All of Minnesota by the Numbers →  •  The Dashboard →  •  The Receipts: every source →  •  The Platform →

Get the next one

New sourced research on Minnesota law, and the deadlines that matter before November 3. Every claim carries its source.

Subscribe Vote 2026: every deadline →

Discussion

Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.