Minnesota protects your IRA from a card company up to a point. The point is $84,000. Past that, you're arguing.
Say you're 45. You've got $150,000 in a traditional IRA, most of it from the 401(k) you rolled over when you changed jobs. A credit card got away from you a few years back, and now a debt buyer has a $20,000 judgment.
Same account, same judgment, in Wisconsin, Iowa or either Dakota: on those facts, the whole IRA is off the table. In Minnesota, the first $84,000 is safe. The other $66,000 is safe only to the extent a court finds you need it to live on. The creditor needs $20,000.
What Minnesota protects
Section 550.37 is the state's main list of what a creditor can't take. Property on it "is not liable to attachment, garnishment, or sale on any final process, issued from any court." Retirement money is subdivision 24:
(a) The debtor's right to receive present or future payments, or payments received by the debtor, under a stock bonus, pension, profit sharing, annuity, individual retirement account, Roth IRA, individual retirement annuity, simplified employee pension, or similar plan or contract on account of illness, disability, death, age, or length of service, to the extent of the debtor's aggregate interest under all plans and contracts up to a present value of $84,000 and additional amounts under all the plans and contracts to the extent reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor and any spouse or dependent of the debtor.
The damage is in the middle: "aggregate interest under all plans and contracts". One cap for everything you've saved, not $84,000 per account. Open five IRAs and you still get one $84,000.
The number floats. Subdivision 4a resets most of the § 550.37 dollar amounts "on July 1 of each even-numbered year" when a federal price index has moved far enough, and only "in multiples of ten percent of the amounts stated in this section." The Department of Commerce's adjustment table puts subdivision 24 at $81,000 from July 1, 2024 and $84,000 from July 1, 2026. If you've seen $81,000 quoted somewhere, it's a cycle stale. This July's raise was $3,000. On a cap meant to hold a working life's retirement savings. Don't spend it all in one place.
Above $84,000, the tail of the sentence takes over: "additional amounts ... to the extent reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor and any spouse or dependent". What's reasonably necessary? Minnesota's statute never says. It gets argued out on your facts, in a fight you didn't pick, over money you saved for a retirement twenty years away.
And the clock runs for the creditor. A Minnesota judgment "survives, and the lien continues, for ten years after its entry." The account keeps growing, and every dollar above the cap is a dollar the creditor can aim at. I covered how long a judgment follows you in the piece on the debt that follows you for a decade.
What the neighbors protect
Wisconsin protects the whole thing, no dollar figure. Section 815.18(3)(j)1. exempts:
Assets held or amounts payable under any retirement, pension, disability, death benefit, stock bonus, profit sharing plan, annuity, individual retirement account, individual retirement annuity, Keogh, 401-K or similar plan or contract providing benefits by reason of age, illness, disability, death or length of service and payments made to the debtor therefrom.
For an IRA, the condition is that "The plan or contract complies with the provisions of the internal revenue code." Wisconsin saves its "reasonably necessary" test for an "owner-dominated plan", the kind set up mostly for the business's owners. Your ordinary IRA isn't that, so nobody asks what you need.
South Dakota lets you pick the number, up to a big one. Section 43-45-16: "Any person has the right to select and designate a total of one million dollars and the income and distributions therefrom from the employee's benefit plans as exempt from execution, attachment, garnishment, seizure, or taking by any legal process." Section 43-45-17 puts IRAs and Roth IRAs on the list by their tax-code sections. The carve-out is South Dakota government, which kept for itself and its political subdivisions "the right ... to collect any amounts owed to them." The state looked out for its own collections first. At least it said so.
North Dakota has a cap, and it's more than double Minnesota's on a single account. Section 28-22-03.1(7) exempts retirement funds "that have been in effect for at least one year," and then: "The value of those assets exempted may not exceed two hundred thousand dollars for any one account or four hundred thousand dollars in aggregate for all accounts." On top of that, the dollar limit "does not apply to the extent this property is reasonably necessary for the support of the resident and that resident's dependents." Same escape valve as Minnesota, bolted onto a much higher ceiling. And North Dakota wrote down what the phrase means: "required to meet present and future needs, as determined by the court after consideration of the resident's responsibilities and all the present and anticipated property and income of the resident, including that which is exempt." Present and future. For a 45-year-old, that's the whole ballgame. Minnesota's statute doesn't say.
Iowa is the one I had to read twice. It doesn't cap the dollars. It traces them. For a traditional IRA, Iowa exempts contributions up to "the actual amount of the contribution deducted on the debtor’s tax return" or the yearly IRA maximum, whichever is less, and the earnings on the exempt share come along proportionally. Then it writes the rollover rule Minnesota never did: "All transfers, in any amount, from an eligible retirement plan to an individual retirement account, an individual retirement annuity, a Roth individual retirement account, or a Roth individual retirement annuity established under section 408A of the Internal Revenue Code shall be exempt from execution and from the claims of creditors." In any amount. The 401(k) that becomes an IRA stays protected in Iowa. Iowa also limits the contributions it counts in the two tax years before the claim to the IRA maximum, so nobody stuffs an account the month the lawsuit lands.
And from farther off, Florida, because nobody says it plainer. An IRA or other account qualified under the tax code "is exempt from all claims of creditors of the owner, beneficiary, or participant". Section 222.21(2)(a). Florida even carries that protection into inherited IRAs, and made it retroactive.
The same $150,000, six ways
The fact pattern: a 45-year-old with a $150,000 traditional IRA, funded mostly by a 401(k) rollover and the rest by deducted contributions, account open for years, and a $20,000 credit card judgment. No bankruptcy.
| State | Statute | What's protected of $150,000 | What a card creditor can reach |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minnesota | § 550.37, subd. 24 | $84,000, plus whatever a court finds "reasonably necessary" for support | Up to $66,000 |
| Wisconsin | § 815.18(3)(j) | $150,000 | $0 |
| South Dakota | §§ 43-45-16, 43-45-17 | $150,000 (designated; $1 million limit) | $0 (debts owed to the state and its political subdivisions excepted) |
| North Dakota | § 28-22-03.1(7) | $150,000 (under the $200,000 per-account limit) | $0 |
| Iowa | § 627.6(8)(f) | $150,000, to the extent it traces to the rollover and deducted contributions | Any share from nondeductible or over-limit contributions, and its earnings |
| Florida | § 222.21(2) | $150,000 | $0 |
| Minnesota, same money left in an ERISA 401(k) | Revisor's note to § 550.37 (ERISA) | $150,000 | $0 |
| Minnesota, in bankruptcy | 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C), (n) | $150,000 (IRA limit $1,711,975, rollovers not counted) | $0 |
Look at the three Minnesota rows. Same person, same $150,000. Leave it in the 401(k): safe. File bankruptcy: safe. Roll it into an IRA when you change jobs, stay out of bankruptcy, and up to $66,000 of it is exposed. Minnesota saves its worst for the debtor who doesn't go bankrupt.
Give Minnesota its due
Money still in an employer plan covered by federal ERISA is out of reach in Minnesota too. The Revisor's note right under § 550.37: "The part of subdivision 24 which limits the amount of a qualified employee benefit plan that is exempt under subdivision 1 is preempted by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA)." In 1995 the state Supreme Court said it plainly: "plans governed by ERISA will continue to be entirely exempt". Thank Congress, not St. Paul. A Minnesotan still gets it.
Bankruptcy is close to a tie, too. A Minnesotan who files can exempt "retirement funds to the extent that those funds are in a fund or account that is exempt from taxation under section 401, 403, 408, 408A, 414, 457, or 501(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986." That's 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C). The IRA ceiling in § 522(n) is $1,711,975 for cases filed on or after April 1, 2025, and money rolled over from an employer plan doesn't count against it.
So the $84,000 cap bites in one place: garnishment and levy, outside bankruptcy. That's exactly where card creditors do their collecting. Bankruptcy is a big step to take over a $20,000 judgment. The law shouldn't make it the price of keeping a retirement account Wisconsin would protect for free.
Twice, Minnesota's statute has carried an unlimited retirement exemption. Twice, a court struck it.
Why it's this way: blame the constitution, partly
The cap isn't just a number the Legislature pulled out of a hat. It sits under two sentences in the state constitution, article I, section 12:
A reasonable amount of property shall be exempt from seizure or sale for the payment of any debt or liability. The amount of such exemption shall be determined by law.
In 1987 the Minnesota Supreme Court read "reasonable amount" as a limit on value. It held two statutes unconstitutional insofar as they gave a "value limitless exemption" to annuities and unmatured life insurance bought from a fraternal benefit society. Quoting its own 1894 decision, it repeated: "The constitutional provision in question prohibits the legislature from exempting an unreasonable amount of property." The court pointed to the retirement subdivision as an example of the right way to do it: its "reasonably necessary" test "clearly passes constitutional scrutiny because it requires a court to limit the size of the exemption based upon objective criteria."
The next year, the Legislature took the limit out anyway. The amendment took effect April 12, 1988. A federal bankruptcy court in Minnesota refused to apply it that same year, writing that "The limitation, however, is no longer there; it is now open to a debtor, in bankruptcy or otherwise, to claim as exempt an unlimited value or amount of money held in the form of any of the accounts or entitlements described in the statute", and held the amended statute void under article I, section 12.
In 1995 the Minnesota Supreme Court took up a later version of the statute, one with an unlimited exemption for IRAs. It held that clause violated the constitution's "reasonable amount" requirement and severed it. What survived, the court said, meant an IRA would "only be exempt up to an indexed $30,000, plus an amount reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor and the debtor’s spouse or dependents." The Legislature deleted the dead clause in 1999 and added Roth IRAs. In 2004 the court said it again: "Nevertheless, to comport with the state constitution, the exemption is subject to monetary limitations."
Call the Legislature stingy and you're only half right. The courts held it to a word in the constitution. But the same 1987 decision said the constitution "requires some value limitation," not that it "requires a specific value limit." A limit and a low limit aren't the same thing. The Commerce table still lists $30,000 as subdivision 24's original figure, the same $30,000 the 1995 court was talking about, and this July's $3,000 raise is ten percent of it. No court made Minnesota pick $84,000. That part's on St. Paul.
Want a big cap with a reasonably-necessary valve on top? North Dakota wrote one, right across the Red River. Wisconsin and Iowa went another way entirely. Any of the three would leave a Minnesotan with a $150,000 IRA better off than the rule we've got.
I covered how the indexing formula shorts the exemptions that share these old bases in the piece on who loses the car. The full list of what Minnesota does protect is in what they cannot take from you.
What we can do
Raise the number, the North Dakota way. Amend § 550.37, subd. 24(a) to replace "up to a present value of $84,000" with North Dakota's structure: "two hundred thousand dollars for any one account or four hundred thousand dollars in aggregate for all accounts", keeping Minnesota's reasonably-necessary clause on top. It's still a limit on value, which is what the 1987 and 2004 decisions said the constitution requires. That's my reading of those decisions. No court has ruled on a number that size.
Write down what "reasonably necessary" means. Borrow North Dakota's definition word for word: "required to meet present and future needs, as determined by the court after consideration of the resident's responsibilities and all the present and anticipated property and income of the resident, including that which is exempt." A 45-year-old's retirement is a future need. The statute should say so.
Stop punishing the rollover. Iowa's sentence protects "All transfers, in any amount, from an eligible retirement plan" into an IRA. An unlimited version would run straight into the 1995 decision. So give rollover money its own cap, the one Congress already picked for IRAs in bankruptcy: § 522(n)'s $1,711,975. Money ERISA fully protected yesterday shouldn't become a card creditor's money because it changed custodians.
And if the constitution is the wall, amend the constitution. Article I, section 12 could carry one more sentence: tax-qualified retirement accounts are exempt, the way Wisconsin and Florida exempt them. Every other dollar in § 550.37 would stay under the "reasonable amount" rule.
A card company doesn't need your whole IRA. It needs $20,000. In Minnesota, it gets to go hunting for it in the other $66,000.
First the facts. Then the fix.
Sources
Minnesota: Minn. Const. art. I, § 12, read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19, 2026. Minn. Stat. § 550.37, subds. 1, 4a(b), 24 and the Revisor's note under § 550.37 on ERISA preemption; § 548.09, subd. 1 (2026 editions), read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19, 2026. Minnesota Department of Commerce, "Historic Adjustments" table, "Restrictions on Deficiency Judgments and Minnesota Property Exemption, Adjustment of Dollar Amounts" (file dated 6.25.26), row 77 (subd. 24: original $30,000; $81,000 effective July 1, 2024; $84,000 effective July 1, 2026).
Court decisions: Minnesota Supreme Court decisions of 1987, 1995 and 2004, and a 1988 decision of the United States Bankruptcy Court for the District of Minnesota, read in the published reports.
Other states: Wis. Stat. § 815.18(3)(j) (2023-24 Stats., updated through 2025 Wis. Act 247) (docs.legis.wisconsin.gov); Iowa Code § 627.6(8)(f) (2026) (legis.iowa.gov); N.D. Cent. Code § 28-22-03.1(7) (ndlegis.gov); S.D. Codified Laws §§ 43-45-16 and 43-45-17 (sdlegislature.gov); Fla. Stat. § 222.21(2) (2026) (leg.state.fl.us). Federal: 11 U.S.C. § 522(b)(3)(C) and (n) (United States Code, 2024 ed., govinfo.gov); Judicial Conference of the United States, Adjustment of Certain Dollar Amounts Applicable to Bankruptcy Cases, 90 Fed. Reg. 8941 (Feb. 4, 2025) (§ 522(n): $1,711,975 for cases commenced on or after April 1, 2025). All read November 19, 2026. The table is my application of those texts to the stated fact pattern.
What I could not establish. Who carries the burden of proving that retirement money above $84,000 is "reasonably necessary", and how Minnesota courts weigh a working-age debtor's future needs, are questions the statute does not answer and this piece does not settle. Iowa's protection depends on where the money in the account came from; a debtor whose IRA was funded with nondeductible contributions has less protected than the table shows. Wisconsin's exemption, for an IRA, turns on a plan that complies with the Internal Revenue Code, and North Dakota's requires an account at least a year old. I did not survey the separate statutes protecting Minnesota's public-employee pensions, which this comparison does not reach, or whether a higher dollar cap in subdivision 24 would survive a constitutional challenge, which no court has decided. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.