She's 55. She did the boring, responsible thing. In her thirties she bought a whole-life policy on her own life. She paid it up, and it hasn't needed a premium in years. Her two grown kids are the beneficiaries. The policy now carries $60,000 of cash value, money she could borrow against tomorrow and the closest thing she has to a savings account. Minnesota leaves most of it on the table for a creditor.

Because she also has a $20,000 credit card judgment against her, held by the bank or by a debt buyer that bought the account.

In Minnesota, $11,200 of that cash value is exempt. The other $48,800 isn't. That covers the judgment more than twice. Move her across the river to Wisconsin and every dollar is protected, with room to spare up to $150,000. North Dakota protects all of it. So do Iowa and Florida, with no dollar cap on a policy like hers. Same woman, same policy. The only thing that changed is the state line.

Minnesota's rule is one sentence with one bad number in it

The whole rule, Minn. Stat. § 550.37, subd. 23:

"The debtor's aggregate interest not to exceed in value $11,200 in any accrued dividends or interest under or loan value of any unmatured life insurance contracts owned by the debtor under which the insured is the debtor or an individual of whom the debtor is a dependent."

In English: loan value is what the policy will lend you against itself. Unmatured means the policy hasn't paid out yet. And aggregate means $11,200 total, across every policy she owns. Not $11,200 a policy.

The number moves, slowly. Subdivision 4a ties most of the dollar amounts in § 550.37 to a federal price index and lets them change "on July 1 of each even-numbered year", and then "only in multiples of ten percent of the amounts stated in this section." The Commerce Department's table of adjustments puts subdivision 23 at $10,800 on July 1, 2024 and $11,200 on July 1, 2026. That's today's figure.

And annuities? In § 550.37 they don't get a line of their own. The word "annuity" shows up in § 550.37 in subdivision 24, the retirement exemption, buried in a list that runs from pensions through IRAs and Roth IRAs, all sharing one aggregate "up to a present value of $84,000" plus whatever is "reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor and any spouse or dependent of the debtor." Whatever an annuity gets under § 550.37, it gets out of the same $84,000 bucket as everything else she saved for old age.

What the neighbors wrote instead

Wisconsin protects the policy, then protects the money inside it. Section 815.18(3)(f)2. covers "any unmatured life insurance or annuity contract owned by the debtor" and insuring the debtor, the debtor's dependent or someone the debtor depends on, and:

"the debtor’s aggregate interest, not to exceed $150,000 in value, in any accrued dividends, interest, or loan value of all unmatured life insurance or annuity contracts owned by the debtor and insuring the debtor, the debtor’s dependent, or an individual of whom the debtor is a dependent."

Sound familiar? It's close to Minnesota's sentence, with annuities added and $150,000 in the blank where we wrote $11,200.

Wisconsin also saw the obvious trick coming. Under (f)3.a., "If the life insurance or annuity contract was issued less than 24 months before the applicable date, the exemption under this paragraph may not exceed $4,000." The applicable date is whichever comes first: the day the exemption is claimed or the day the lawsuit behind the judgment was filed. A policy funded within that 24-month window gets a similar $4,000 limit on the new money. See a lawsuit coming, pour your checking account into a new policy the week before it's filed, and you've bought $4,000 of protection, tops. Her policy has been paid up for years, so in Wisconsin all $60,000 is exempt.

North Dakota gets there in two subsections. Section 28-22-03.1(4) lets a resident claim:

"Any unmatured life insurance contract owned by the debtor, other than a credit life insurance contract."

That's the policy itself. Subsection (5) then protects the value inside it, the debtor's aggregate interest "not to exceed in value one hundred thousand dollars less any amount of property transferred in the manner specified in 11 U.S.C. 542(d)" in accrued dividends, interest or loan value, with its own guardrail: "Any cash deposit not previously scheduled to be made into a life insurance policy or nonqualified annuity over the previous twelve months is not exempt." Her $60,000 sits under the $100,000. All of it is exempt.

I read Minnesota's subdivision 23 next to North Dakota's subsection (5) twice, because they're nearly the same sentence. Same phrases, both of them: "aggregate interest", "loan value of", "unmatured life insurance" and "under which the insured is the debtor or an individual of whom the debtor is a dependent". Congress used the same words in the Bankruptcy Code's own exemption list, 11 U.S.C. § 522(d)(8). Same sentence, three blanks. The federal blank holds $16,850 for bankruptcy cases filed on or after April 1, 2025. North Dakota's holds $100,000. Minnesota's holds $11,200, less than the federal figure. Ours is the smallest of the three.

Iowa didn't bother with a number. Section 627.6(6) exempts:

"The interest of an individual in any accrued dividend or interest, loan or cash surrender value of, or any other interest in a life insurance policy owned by the individual if the beneficiary of the policy is the individual’s spouse, child, or dependent."

Iowa's limit is on new money: the exemption "shall not exceed ten thousand dollars in the aggregate of any interest or value in insurance acquired within two years" of the execution or the exemption claim, and the same applies to additions to an existing policy beyond what it takes to fund the coverage. Her beneficiaries are her kids, and nothing new went in. Iowa protects all $60,000. It would protect $600,000.

Florida doesn't use a number either. Section 222.14:

"The cash surrender values of life insurance policies issued upon the lives of citizens or residents of the state and the proceeds of annuity contracts issued to citizens or residents of the state, upon whatever form, shall not in any case be liable to attachment, garnishment or legal process in favor of any creditor of the person whose life is so insured or of any creditor of the person who is the beneficiary of such annuity contract, unless the insurance policy or annuity contract was effected for the benefit of such creditor."

Read "shall not in any case" again. Annuity proceeds too, same sentence. Florida first passed it in 1925 and amended it in 1978, and a century later it still reads stronger than Minnesota's 2026 statute.

Her policy, state by state

Line her up in five states. I've treated the whole $60,000 as the policy's loan value, because Minnesota's, Wisconsin's and North Dakota's statutes count loan value and Florida's and Iowa's count cash surrender value. The last column is a different question: what a policy pays out after a death, protected from the surviving beneficiary's own creditors.

State Cash value protected Of her $60,000, exempt Proceeds protected from the beneficiary's own creditors
Minnesota $11,200 (§ 550.37, subd. 23) $11,200; $48,800 is not $56,000, plus $14,000 per dependent (§ 550.37, subd. 10)
Wisconsin The policy, plus $150,000 of value; $4,000 if issued within 24 months before the claim or the lawsuit (§ 815.18(3)(f)) All $60,000 Only what's reasonably necessary for support, and only if she was the insured's dependent (§ 815.18(3)(i)1.a.)
North Dakota The policy, plus $100,000 of value (§ 28-22-03.1(4), (5)) All $60,000 Not in the statutes I read
Iowa No dollar cap if the beneficiary is a spouse, child or dependent; $10,000 on insurance acquired in the last two years (§ 627.6(6)) All $60,000 $15,000, against debts from before the death (§ 627.6(6)(c))
Florida No dollar cap (§ 222.14) All $60,000 The statute's text names the insured's creditors only (§ 222.13(1))
South Dakota Not part of this comparison Not part of this comparison $20,000 (§ 58-12-4)

Five states, one policy. Four of them protect every dollar. Minnesota protects less than a fifth.

Now give Minnesota its due

Flip the question and Minnesota wins, and not by a little. When a policy pays out at a death, Minnesota protects the widow from her own creditors better than Iowa or South Dakota, and further than the text of Florida's statute goes. Subdivision 10:

"All money received by, or payable to, a surviving spouse or child from insurance payable at the death of a spouse, or parent, not exceeding $56,000. The $56,000 exemption provided by this subdivision shall be increased by $14,000 for each dependent of the surviving spouse or child."

Say her husband dies and leaves a $50,000 policy, and she's carrying her own $20,000 card judgment. In Minnesota all $50,000 is under the cap and exempt. Two dependents, and the cap is $84,000. Iowa protects $15,000 from "liability for all debts of the beneficiary contracted prior to death of the insured", and the other $35,000 is open to the judgment. South Dakota protects proceeds "to the total amount of twenty thousand dollars only," leaving $30,000 exposed. Florida's § 222.13 makes proceeds "exempt from the claims of creditors of the insured"; the Florida statutes I read say nothing about the widow's own creditors. Wisconsin protects a payout only "to the extent reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor and the debtor’s dependents", and only when she was the insured's dependent.

Minnesota covers the other direction too. Under § 61A.12, subd. 1, "When any insurance is effected in favor of another, the beneficiary shall be entitled to its proceeds against the creditors and representatives of the person effecting the same." The dead man's creditors don't get the widow's check. They do get one consolation prize: the same subdivision hands them back any premiums paid in fraud of them, with interest, if the insurer gets written notice before it pays.

Two catches. The subdivision 10 money stays exempt after it goes into a bank account "if the funds are traceable to their exempt source", and "The burden of establishing that funds are exempt rests upon the debtor." Keep the paper trail. And subdivision 10 reaches a surviving spouse or child. A policy left to your sister or your best friend isn't in it.

So why $11,200?

The record I have doesn't say why Minnesota picked the number it picked. It does show how the number got here.

The Commerce Department's table lists $4,000 as subdivision 23's original amount. Every move on that table since has been a multiple of $400, which is ten percent of $4,000, the ten-percent step subdivision 4a describes, measured on the table's original figure. The table's 2022 figure was $10,400, then $10,800 in 2024, then $11,200 in 2026. That's indexing doing its job on a small number. Index a small number and you get a slightly bigger small number. Nothing on the table looks like a raise beyond the formula. I've written about how that formula falls behind prices in an earlier piece.

And the Legislature had this exact statute open in 2024. The Revisor's history line for § 550.37 ends with Laws 2024, chapter 114, article 3, sections 84 through 94, the same article that wrote the new wage-garnishment tiers I covered in What a Paycheck Loses. Eleven sections of § 550.37 amendments, and one of them, section 92, amended subdivision 23 itself: "dividend" became "dividends" and "contract" became "contracts". It left the dollar amount alone. Two plurals, same number. The cash-value figure still moved $400 that July, the same step the formula would have taken anyway.

Wisconsin wrote $150,000. North Dakota wrote $100,000 and protected the policy too. Minnesota likes to call itself the progressive one in the neighborhood. On what a family keeps from a card creditor, North Dakota just lapped it.

What we can do about it

Change one number. In § 550.37, subd. 23, strike "$11,200" and write "$150,000", Wisconsin's figure. Keep subdivision 4a's indexing on top of it.

Protect the policy, not just the money inside it. Add North Dakota's sentence, word for word, as its own subdivision: "Any unmatured life insurance contract owned by the debtor, other than a credit life insurance contract." The federal Bankruptcy Code's list carries the same line at § 522(d)(7). It's already written.

Put annuities in the same line. Wisconsin's (f)2. reads "life insurance or annuity contract". Borrow "or annuity" so an annuity isn't left fighting for room under the retirement cap.

Borrow the guardrails, too. The creditors have one fair objection: an uncapped policy is a place to hide money from a judgment. Wisconsin and North Dakota already answered it, in statute text: $4,000 on a contract issued, or new money paid in, within 24 months before the claim or the lawsuit, whichever came first, and nothing for an unscheduled deposit in the last twelve months. Copy them. That protects the policy you've paid into for 20 years and stops the deposit made with a lawsuit on the way.

Leave subdivision 10 alone. It beats Iowa's and South Dakota's by a mile. Don't let a fix to subdivision 23 become the excuse to trim it.

Minnesota takes good care of your life insurance once you're dead. It's while you're alive that it lets the card creditor in.

First the facts. Then the fix.


Sources

Minnesota Statutes § 550.37, subds. 4a, 10, 20, 23 and 24, and the section's history line, and § 61A.12, subd. 1 (2026 editions), read at revisor.mn.gov on November 19, 2026. Minnesota Department of Commerce, "Historic Adjustments" (file dated 6.25.26), the indexed-amounts table for § 550.37, read at mn.gov on November 19, 2026. Laws 2024, ch. 114, art. 3, as listed in the § 550.37 history line, and art. 3, § 92 as enacted (revisor.mn.gov, read November 21, 2026); the wage-garnishment tiers in the same article from the November 6, 2026 garnishment research.

Other states: Wis. Stat. § 815.18(3)(f)1.–3. and (3)(i)1.a. (2023–24 Wis. Stats., updated through 2025 Wis. Act 247; docs.legis.wisconsin.gov); N.D. Cent. Code §§ 28-22-03.1(4) and (5) and 26.1-33-40 (ndlegis.gov); Iowa Code § 627.6(6), (6)(a) and (6)(c) (Iowa Code 2026; legis.iowa.gov); Fla. Stat. §§ 222.13(1) and 222.14 (2026), with § 222.14's history note (leg.state.fl.us); S.D. Codified Laws § 58-12-4 (sdlegislature.gov). Federal: 11 U.S.C. § 522(d)(7) and (d)(8) (2024 ed.; govinfo.gov), and the Judicial Conference's notice of adjusted dollar amounts, 90 Fed. Reg. 8941 (Feb. 4, 2025). All read November 19, 2026. The table is my arithmetic on those texts, with the policy facts and the loan-value assumption stated above.

What I could not establish. I did not read South Dakota's rules on a living policyholder's cash value, so the table leaves that cell out. The Florida statutes I read, §§ 222.13 and 222.14, do not protect death-benefit proceeds from the beneficiary's own creditors, and I did not survey Florida case law on the point. The record I have does not show why subdivision 23 started at $4,000, when it was enacted, or whether any bill has proposed raising it; I did not search the bill record for this piece. I did not research how a creditor goes about reaching the non-exempt cash value of a Minnesota policy, or how Minnesota's other insurance statutes, including § 61A.12, subd. 2 for policies payable to a spouse, interact with subdivision 23. Loan value and cash surrender value are not always the same figure; the table treats them as equal. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.

Related research

Chosen by shared subject and shared statute, not by date.

Minnesota by the Numbers

Wisconsin, Iowa and the Dakotas Can Protect All of a $150,000 IRA From a Card Judgment. Minnesota Protects $84,000 of It.

A $150,000 IRA meets a $20,000 credit card judgment. Minnesota protects $84,000 and leaves up to $66,000 on the table. Wisconsin, South Dakota and Florida…

Also turns on Minn. Stat. § 550.37 and § 627.6
Minnesota by the Numbers

A $20,000 Card Judgment Can Reach $30,200 of a Minnesota Family's Furniture and Cars. Kansas Puts No Dollar Cap on the Couch and Protects a $20,000 Car.

Two parents, $30,000 of furniture and electronics, a $15,000 car, an $8,000 car, and a $20,000 card judgment against one of them. Minnesota protects $12,600 of…

Also turns on Minn. Stat. § 550.37 and § 815.18
Minnesota by the Numbers

A Minnesota Bank Can Freeze All $3,000 in Your Checking Account Over a Card Judgment. In New York, the Same Freeze Is Void.

A $3,000 checking balance, half of it last Friday's paycheck, and a $20,000 credit card judgment. A Minnesota bank can hold every dollar, and you get 14 days to…

Also turns on Minn. Stat. § 550.37
← PreviousJudgment interest112 of 114 in Minnesota by the NumbersNext →Spousal liability

All of Minnesota by the Numbers →  •  The Dashboard →  •  The Receipts: every source →  •  The Platform →

Get the next one

New sourced research on Minnesota law, and the deadlines that matter before November 3. Every claim carries its source.

Subscribe Vote 2026: every deadline →

Discussion

Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.