Your paycheck comes up short. There's a new line on the stub, and the money went to a company you may never have heard of.
In Minnesota, the odds say that line is a credit card debt. They also say there's about an even chance the company on the other end bought the debt instead of lending it. Texas wouldn't allow that line on the stub. Neither would Pennsylvania or South Carolina. And the Legislature's own first draft in 2024 would have shrunk it far more than the law that passed.
Who's on the other end of the garnishment
Every wage garnishment for a consumer debt starts with a lawsuit, so start there.
In 2019, debt collection suits were 51 percent of Minnesota's entire civil docket, according to the Minnesota State Bar Association's 2023 statewide report. Our courts "see four times as many debt cases as they do evictions". In a random sample of district-court debt suits from 2018 through 2021, 95 percent were over credit card debt. In conciliation court it was three-quarters. Among the state's top plaintiffs from 2017 to 2019, debt buyers filed half of all the suits, and credit card companies and banks another 21 percent.
The newer numbers put names on it. Princeton's Debt Collection Lab, working from Minnesota court records, counts 60,765 debt suits in 2024. LVNV Funding, a debt buyer, filed 17,471 of them. That's 28.8 percent of every debt suit in the state from one company. The top ten plaintiffs filed 66.9 percent.
Most of these cases are over before they start: 82 percent of district-court debt cases end in a default judgment for the plaintiff. Then the bill grows. The MSBA's own example takes a $1,000 district-court claim and, after fees, attorney fees, interest and the garnishment fee, turns it into a $2,042.72 judgment within a year.
Those are lawsuits. How many Minnesotans actually get garnished? Nobody knows, and the bar association that studied the docket says why:
"The processes for enforcing a judgment are largely handled by plaintiffs, taking place outside of the purview of the courts; as a result, there is limited court data available to understand the impact of post-judgment activity on Minnesota consumers."
In Minnesota the plaintiff's lawyer, not the court, prepares the garnishment summons. So the state can tell you how many debt suits were filed last year, down to the plaintiff. It can't tell you how many paychecks those suits reached.
What Minnesota law lets them do
Section 571.71 lets a creditor in "a civil action for the recovery of money" issue a garnishment summons once it has a money judgment. Nothing in it treats a credit card debt or a debt buyer differently from anybody else.
It doesn't even have to wait for the judgment. Clause (2) allows garnishment "at any time 45 days or more after service of the summons and complaint" when a default "could have, but has not, been entered". The creditor serves a Notice of Intent to Garnish and an exemption form, and the debtor gets 25 days to answer. Then:
"No filing of a pleading or other documents by the creditor is required to issue a garnishment summons under this clause; however, the creditor must comply with the service requirement of section 571.72, subdivision 4"
Garnishing on a lawsuit nobody filed sounds like a typo. It isn't. The Legislature printed the warning right on the statutory notice in § 548.101: "Under Minnesota law, a lawsuit may be started against you even though it has not yet been filed in court and the court has no record of this lawsuit or this paperwork." I had to read that one twice.
How much can they take? Section 571.922 sets three tiers, picked by weekly gross pay and applied to disposable pay. At Minnesota's 2026 minimum wage of $11.41, the first $456.40 a week is protected. Up to $684.60, a creditor gets 10 percent. Up to $912.80, 15 percent. Over $912.80, which is $22.82 an hour at 40 hours, it's 25 percent. That's the federal maximum.
I've called these brackets good policy before. For a lower-wage worker, they are. At $18 an hour, running each state's formula on Minnesota's minimum wage, Minnesota takes less than 11 of the 15 percentage-rule states I compared.
But they're newer and narrower than you'd think. They came in 2024. A 2025 amendment made them effective "June 1, 2025, and applies to causes of action commenced on or after that date." And the statutes for execution levies on earnings, § 550.136, subd. 3, and attorney's summary execution, § 551.06, subd. 3, still print a flat "25 percent". The Legislature re-enacted both subdivisions in its 2025 special session and left the 25 percent right where it was.
What other states decided
Federal law caps what a creditor can take, and it lets a state go lower. Its limits do "not annul, alter, or affect ... the laws of any State (1) prohibiting garnishments or providing for more limited garnishment than are allowed under this subchapter". Some states said no.
Texas put it in its constitution:
"No current wages for personal service shall ever be subject to garnishment, except for the enforcement of court-ordered: (1) child support payments; or (2) spousal maintenance."
That's all of it. No tiers, no worksheet.
In Pennsylvania, "The wages, salaries and commissions of individuals shall while in the hands of the employer be exempt from any attachment, execution or other process", except for a short list that includes support, divorce, residential landlords at up to 10 percent of net pay, the state student loan agency, and criminal restitution and fines. A credit card isn't on it.
South Carolina aimed straight at consumer credit: "With respect to a debt arising from a consumer credit sale, a consumer lease, a consumer loan, or a consumer rental-purchase agreement, regardless of where made, the creditor may not attach unpaid earnings of the debtor by garnishment or like proceedings." Its code counts debt created "pursuant to a lender credit card or similar arrangement" as a loan.
North Carolina gets close. Earnings from the 60 days before the order can't be applied to a judgment when they're "necessary for the use of a family supported wholly or partly by his labor." So it generally keeps a card creditor off a family's paycheck, but it turns on that showing.
New York didn't ban it. It capped it at 10 percent of gross pay, and it protects the whole check when disposable pay is at or below 30 times the greater of the federal or state minimum wage.
One limit on the no-garnishment states: federal student-loan garnishment runs "Notwithstanding any provision of State law," up to 15 percent of disposable pay. The protection is against private consumer creditors.
Here's one Minnesota worker, 40 hours a week, under each rule. I've assumed disposable pay is 80 percent of gross, $576 at $18 an hour and $960 at $30. Where a state's formula runs off that state's own minimum wage, I plugged in Minnesota's $11.41, so this is a Minnesota paycheck run through the other state's formula. At Illinois's own $15 wage, Illinois would take nothing from the $18 check. It's an illustration, not a tax table. Treat the dollars as ballpark.
| Rule applied to a Minnesota worker | $18 an hour, taken per week | $30 an hour, taken per week |
|---|---|---|
| Minnesota today (§ 571.922) | $86.40 | $240.00 |
| Federal maximum | $144.00 | $240.00 |
| Texas, Pennsylvania, South Carolina | $0 | $0 |
| North Carolina, family-support showing made | $0 | $0 |
| New York | $72.00 | $120.00 |
| Illinois | $62.55 | $180.00 |
| Delaware or Massachusetts | $108.00 | $180.00 |
| Minnesota's 2024 first draft, with its floor figured at today's $11.41 | $0 | $47.20 |
The $30-an-hour Minnesotan loses $240 a week, $12,480 a year. New York would take half that. Texas would take nothing.
The first draft had the same flaw as the 2020 law: it pointed its floor at the old $9.50 rate. As written, it would take $96.00 a week from the $30-an-hour worker. Figured at today's wage, $47.20.
The tiers also have a cliff. Gross pay picks the bracket and the bracket hits the whole disposable check, so one cent over $912.80 a week moves a worker from 15 to 25 percent. That's another 10 percent of disposable pay for a one-cent raise.
What the cards cost, and what the president said
The garnishment is the back end of a business. Here's the front end, from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's December 2025 report to Congress.
In 2024, "the average annual percentage rate (APR) reached 25.2 percent for general purpose cards". Consumers "were assessed $160 billion in interest charges, up from $105 billion in 2022." The APR margin, the spread issuers set above the prime rate, "reached a new high in 2024 at 16.4 percent". And when an account goes bad: "In 2024, the overall average price of charged-off debt declined to 11 percent of the account balance".
Eleven cents on the dollar. That's what a dead card account is worth to the bank that gives up on it. It's worth a lot more to whoever can reach a paycheck.
Donald Trump has been saying since 2024 that the rates are too high. His words, straight from the record:
At a rally in Uniondale, New York, on September 18, 2024: "We're going to cap it at around 10%. We can't let them make 25% and 30%."
On Truth Social on January 9, 2026: "we will no longer let the American Public be 'ripped off' by Credit Card Companies that are charging Interest Rates of 20 to 30%, and even more". The quotation marks around "ripped off" are his.
Aboard Air Force One on January 11, 2026: "They really—they've really abused the public. The credit card companies have totally abused."
At Davos on January 21, 2026: "Whatever happened to usury?" And: "I'm asking Congress to cap credit card interest rates at 10 percent for one year". In the same passage he put card companies' profit margin over 50 percent. I can't source that number, so I'm not using it. The CFPB's 16.4 percent is a different measure, and it's bad enough.
Congress already has a 10 percent cap in front of it. Two of them, both filed before his January call. S. 381, from Senator Bernard Sanders, an independent, with Republican Senator Hawley as a cosponsor, was introduced February 4, 2025. H.R. 1944, from Democratic Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, with Republican Representative Anna Paulina Luna as a cosponsor, came March 6, 2025. Both run to 2031, not one year. On congress.gov, the last action on each is the committee referral the day it was introduced. Nothing since.
Both bills say: "Nothing in this section may be construed to preempt any provision of State law that provides greater protection to consumers than is provided under this section." Washington won't stop Minnesota from doing better. Washington isn't doing much of anything.
So why hasn't the Legislature done more?
The record answers part of that. The motives belong to the people who have them.
Since 2019 the Legislature has rewritten how much can be taken twice, and patched it once. The first bill came from two Republicans, Senator Housley and Representative Davids, passed the Senate 67–0 in 2019, and became law in 2020 through S.F. 3357, unanimous in both chambers. It raised the protected floor to 40 times the state minimum wage. Except the state wage it pointed at was "$9.50 per hour beginning August 1, 2016". So from August 1, 2020 to June 30, 2025, almost five years, the floor sat at $380 a week. A 2024 law renumbered the pointer and kept it aimed at the same $9.50. The 2025 special session fixed it, effective July 1, 2025.
The second was 2024. H.F. 4100 from Representative Reyer and S.F. 4065 from Senator Boldon, both DFL, with a matching S.F. 4602 from DFL Senator Kupec, started at a 10 percent cap with everything below 80 times the minimum wage protected. Committee changed that to 25, 15 and 5 percent. The Senate passed its commerce bill, S.F. 4097, 53–14 with nothing on garnishment. The House put that into its version of S.F. 4097 and passed it 70–61. The conference committee wrote today's 25, 15 and 10. The whole commerce bill carrying it passed the Senate 34–32 and the House 70–58 and was signed May 21, 2024. Then a 2025 law pushed the start date from April 1 to June 1, 2025.
What's missing? From 2019 through 2026, the Revisor's bill-text search turns up no bill to end wage garnishment for consumer debt, and none aimed at credit card or debt-buyer judgments.
The Legislature knows how to guard a paycheck when it wants to. In 2023 it told hospitals that to sue or garnish over medical debt, they must serve an affidavit of expert review certifying "there is no reasonable basis to believe that the patient's or guarantor's wages or funds at a financial institution are likely to be exempt from garnishment". Skip it and, upon motion, the result is "mandatory dismissal with prejudice".
Then the 2024 act wrote card debt out of the new medical-debt chapter: there, medical debt "does not include" "debt charged to a credit card or other credit instrument, under an open-end or closed-end credit plan, that is not offered specifically to pay for health treatment or services". And the hospital affidavit covers only medical debt "owed to a hospital". Put the ER bill on your Visa and the hospital has been paid. The card company can sue and garnish with no affidavit, at up to 25 percent.
Section 103 of the same act tells the attorney general, in recommending revisions to the garnishment forms, to "obtain approval from affected business and consumer groups". The first five it names are the Minnesota Creditors' Rights Association, the Great Lakes Credit and Collections Association, the Minnesota Bankers' Association, the Minnesota Credit Union Network and BankIn Minnesota. For 2024, the Campaign Finance Board's files show those five reporting a combined $653,000 in lobbying spending. Encore Capital Group and PRA Group reported $24,000 and $30,000, their first rows in the Board's files. The Pew Charitable Trusts calls Encore and Portfolio Recovery Associates two of the largest publicly traded debt buyers. Those are totals across every subject each group lobbied on. The files don't say a dollar of it was about garnishment, and I'm not saying it either.
The other side's best case
Here's the best case I can make for the creditors, in my words, because the conference committee's reasons aren't in the bill record. A judgment is a court's finding that money is owed, and garnishment is how a judgment gets paid when the debtor doesn't pay. Take the paycheck off the table, the argument goes, and a creditor loses its main tool and the cost lands on everyone who does pay. The other side can also say, fairly, that the 2024 tiers already cut what a lower-wage worker loses, and that Minnesota takes less than most of the states I compared at $18 an hour. Texas and Pennsylvania have had credit cards for as long as the rest of us. Their answer to that argument is the one above.
What we can do
Take the paycheck off the table for credit card and debt-buyer judgments. Texas did it in its constitution, Pennsylvania and South Carolina by statute, and federal law expressly lets a state go that far. Keep the exceptions those states keep, like child support.
At minimum, pass the Legislature's own first draft, pointed at today's wage. Ten percent, and nothing below 80 times the current minimum wage. Reyer, Boldon and Kupec already wrote the rest of it. At today's $11.41 it leaves the $18-an-hour worker's check alone and takes $47.20 a week from the $30-an-hour worker instead of $240.
Finish the job. Write the tiers into §§ 550.136 and 551.06, so the levy statutes say in plain words what the garnishment statute says. And reach judgments from suits started before June 1, 2025. A family garnished on a 2024 case pays the same rent as one garnished on a 2026 case.
Count the garnishments. Have every garnishment summons filed or reported, with the creditor, the original creditor and the amount, and have the Judicial Branch publish the totals every year. The state can tell you how many suits LVNV filed. It should be able to tell you how many paychecks they reached.
Keep Minnesota's law stronger, whatever Congress does. If S. 381 ever moves, its own text preserves stronger state law. So does the federal garnishment statute. Minnesota doesn't have to wait for Washington.
Three states decided a credit card company doesn't get your paycheck. Minnesota's Legislature wrote half that idea down in 2024 and passed something else. The draft's still on file.
Sources
Minnesota Statutes §§ 571.71, 571.72, 571.75, 571.921, 571.922, 548.101, 550.136, 550.37, 551.01, 551.06, 144.588, 332C.01, 177.24 (2026 and 2022 editions) and 645.02, read at revisor.mn.gov on November 6, 2026. Session laws: Laws 2020, ch. 86, art. 4; Laws 2023, ch. 70, art. 4, § 41; Laws 2024, ch. 110, art. 6, § 5; Laws 2024, ch. 114, art. 3, §§ 101 and 103; Laws 2025, ch. 18, § 21; Laws 2025, 1st Spec. Sess., ch. 4, art. 7, §§ 32–34. Bill text, history and votes for H.F. 2065, S.F. 1706, S.F. 3357, H.F. 4100, S.F. 4065, S.F. 4602, H.F. 4077, S.F. 4097, S.F. 3852, S.F. 2847 and H.F. 4 (2025, 1st Spec. Sess.) from the Revisor's bill pages; chief authors' parties from the Legislative Reference Library. Minimum wage: Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry, "Minimum wage in Minnesota", $11.41 as of January 1, 2026.
Other states: Tex. Const. art. XVI, § 28 and Tex. Prop. Code § 42.001 (tcss.legis.texas.gov); 42 Pa.C.S. § 8127 (palegis.us); S.C. Code §§ 37-5-104, 37-3-104, 37-3-106 and 15-39-410 (scstatehouse.gov); N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 1-362 and 1C-1601 (ncleg.gov); N.Y. CPLR 5231 (nysenate.gov); 735 ILCS 5/12-803 and 820 ILCS 105/4; 10 Del. C. § 4913; Mass. Gen. Laws c. 246, § 28. Federal: 15 U.S.C. §§ 1673 and 1677; 20 U.S.C. § 1095a; 29 U.S.C. § 206. All read November 6, 2026. The worker table is my arithmetic on those texts, with the 80 percent disposable-pay assumption and the Minnesota-wage substitution stated above.
Lawsuit data: Minnesota State Bar Association Access to Justice Committee, "Minnesota Consumer Debt Litigation: A Statewide Access to Justice Report" (October 2023), pp. 3, 4, 13, 16, 18, 24 and 28 and Table 4; Debt Collection Lab (Princeton), Lawsuit Tracker, Minnesota data file, with counts by year and plaintiff computed from it; Human Rights Watch, "Rubber Stamp Justice" (January 2016), n. 19.
Credit card data: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, "The Consumer Credit Card Market", report to Congress, December 2025, pp. 5, 48, 51 and 94.
Presidential statements: Roll Call Factba.se transcript of the September 18, 2024 Uniondale, New York rally; Truth Social post of January 9, 2026, 8:10 p.m. Eastern, from the Internet Archive's capture of the post's own record; Daily Compilation of Presidential Documents DCPD-202600015 (January 11, 2026) and DCPD-202600046 (January 21, 2026), govinfo.gov. Federal bills: S. 381 and H.R. 1944, 119th Congress, text from govinfo.gov and actions and cosponsors from the congress.gov API.
Lobbying: Minnesota Campaign Finance and Public Disclosure Board, Principal Expenditures 2009–Present download, report years 2019–2025, retrieved November 6, 2026. Encore and Portfolio Recovery Associates described from The Pew Charitable Trusts, "How Debt Collectors Are Transforming the Business of State Courts" (May 2020).
What I could not establish. No public record counts Minnesota wage garnishments, by creditor or in total; the figures above count lawsuits filed, which is the step every consumer-debt garnishment passes through. The Debt Collection Lab lists plaintiffs, not the type of debt each one sued on, and its Minnesota counts can differ from the courts' own because of how it selects cases; LVNV Funding's identity as a debt buyer comes from a 2016 Human Rights Watch report, not a Minnesota record. North Carolina's protection depends on a family-support showing, and I did not survey its special-purpose garnishments for taxes or public creditors. The Board's bulk lobbying files report totals across all subjects and do not list what any group lobbied on. The conference committee's deliberations on the 2024 garnishment language are not in the bill record. How courts apply the 2024 tiers to judgments from suits filed before June 1, 2025, and whether § 550.37, subd. 13 carries those tiers into execution levies, are legal questions this piece does not answer. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.