Two hundred forty dollars a week. That's what a creditor holding a judgment can take from a Minnesotan who earns $30 an hour. Over a year it's $12,480. It's also the most federal law allows anywhere in the country. Minnesota is free to take less. Above $22.82 an hour, full time, it doesn't bother.
I ran one Minnesota paycheck through the garnishment rules of nineteen other states and the federal government. Minnesota looks good at $18 an hour. Then it doesn't.
| Rule, applied to one Minnesota worker | What it says, in a line | $18 an hour, taken per week | $30 an hour, taken per week |
|---|---|---|---|
| Texas | No garnishment of current wages except child support and spousal maintenance (Const. art. XVI, § 28) | $0 | $0 |
| Pennsylvania | Wages exempt except support, divorce, board, residential landlords, the state student-loan agency, restitution and fines (42 Pa.C.S. § 8127) | $0 | $0 |
| South Carolina | No garnishment on a consumer credit sale, lease or loan, including a lender credit card (§ 37-5-104) | $0 | $0 |
| North Carolina, family-support showing made | 60 days of earnings protected when needed for a family the debtor supports (§ 1-362) | $0 | $0 |
| Missouri, head of family | 10 percent (§ 525.030) | $57.60 | $96.00 |
| New York | 10 percent of gross, never more than 25 percent of disposable (CPLR 5231) | $72.00 | $120.00 |
| California | Lesser of 20 percent, or 40 percent of pay above 48 times the minimum wage (CCP § 706.050) | $11.33 | $164.93 |
| Illinois | Lesser of 15 percent of gross, or pay above 45 times the minimum wage (735 ILCS 5/12-803) | $62.55 | $180.00 |
| Delaware | 15 percent (10 Del. C. § 4913) | $108.00 | $180.00 |
| Massachusetts | 15 percent of gross, with 50 times the minimum wage protected (c. 246, § 28) | $108.00 | $180.00 |
| Hawaii | 5, 10 and 20 percent brackets, figured monthly (HRS § 652-1) | $109.43 | $186.23 |
| Colorado | 20 percent, with 40 times the minimum wage protected (C.R.S. § 13-54-104) | $115.20 | $192.00 |
| Washington, consumer debt | 20 percent, with 35 times the minimum wage protected (RCW 6.27.150) | $115.20 | $192.00 |
| Nevada | 18 percent at $770 a week or less, 25 percent above (NRS 31.295) | $103.68 | $240.00 |
| New Mexico | 25 percent, with 40 times the highest applicable minimum wage protected (NMSA § 35-12-7) | $119.60 | $240.00 |
| Virginia | 25 percent, with 40 times the minimum wage protected (§ 34-29) | $119.60 | $240.00 |
| Oregon | 25 percent, with $400 a week protected (ORS 18.385) | $144.00 | $240.00 |
| Maryland | 25 percent, with 30 times the minimum wage protected (Com. Law § 15-601.1) | $144.00 | $240.00 |
| New Hampshire | Federal 25 percent, and a writ reaches only wages already earned when it's served (RSA 512:21) | $144.00 | $240.00 |
| Federal maximum | Lesser of 25 percent, or pay above 30 times $7.25 (15 U.S.C. § 1673) | $144.00 | $240.00 |
| Minnesota | 10, 15 or 25 percent, by weekly gross pay (§ 571.922) | $86.40 | $240.00 |
The worker puts in 40 hours a week. I've assumed disposable pay, what's left after required withholding, is 80 percent of gross: $576 a week at $18 an hour and $960 at $30. Where a state's formula runs off its own minimum wage, I plugged in Minnesota's $11.41, so every row is a Minnesota paycheck run through the other state's formula. At Illinois's own $15 wage, Illinois would take nothing from the $18 check. Call the dollars ballpark. The percentages are the law.
Four states said no
Texas put it in its constitution: "No current wages for personal service shall ever be subject to garnishment, except for the enforcement of court-ordered: (1) child support payments; or (2) spousal maintenance." That's the whole rule. No worksheet, no cliff.
Pennsylvania exempts wages in the employer's hands from attachment. The exceptions make a short list, and a credit card isn't on it. South Carolina went straight at consumer credit. A creditor on a consumer credit sale, lease or loan "may not attach unpaid earnings of the debtor by garnishment or like proceedings", and the code counts debt run up on a lender credit card as a loan. The bar reaches consumer loans up to a principal limit the code sets at $25,000 and indexes to consumer prices, or of any size if secured by land.
North Carolina generally keeps a card creditor off a family's paycheck, but it turns on a showing. Earnings from the 60 days before the order can't be applied to the judgment when they're needed for a family the debtor supports.
Congress made room for this. Federal law says its garnishment limits do "not annul, alter, or affect ... the laws of any State (1) prohibiting garnishments or providing for more limited garnishment than are allowed under this subchapter". Congress set a ceiling and let the states build under it. These four went all the way to the floor, North Carolina on a showing. What they can't stop is federal student-loan garnishment, which overrides state law at up to 15 percent of disposable pay.
Same worker, one raise
At $18 an hour, the Minnesota worker grosses $720 a week and lands in the 15 percent tier. The creditor gets $86.40 a week, $4,492.80 a year. Run on Minnesota's wage, eleven of the fifteen percentage-rule states in the table would take more. Only New York, Illinois, Missouri's head-of-family rule and California take less, plus the four that take nothing. The 2024 Legislature did right by that worker. Hold that thought.
Now give the same worker a raise. At $30 an hour, $1,200 gross, Minnesota takes $240 a week: 25 percent of disposable pay, the federal maximum, to the dollar. Nine percentage-rule states take less. New York takes half. Six tie Minnesota at the ceiling on Minnesota's wage. The federal cap stops anyone going over.
Find Minnesota in the table. Bottom row, next to the federal government, at the most Congress lets anyone take. Past $22.82 an hour, full time, Minnesota's percentage is the federal one. Not a better version. The same one. Under New York's rule, that $30-an-hour worker keeps another $6,240 a year. Under Texas's, all $12,480.
Minnesota's rule, minus the worksheet
The first 40 times the state minimum wage is off limits. At 2026's $11.41, that's $456.40 a week. Above that sit three tiers. The statute's own worksheet picks the tier by weekly gross pay, then takes the percentage out of disposable pay:
- More than $456.40 and up to $684.60 gross: 10 percent.
- More than $684.60 and up to $912.80: 15 percent.
- More than $912.80, which is $22.82 an hour at 40 hours: 25 percent.
And a creditor can never take more than the amount by which disposable pay exceeds that $456.40.
Then there's the cliff. Gross pay picks the bracket and the bracket hits the whole disposable check, so one cent over $912.80 a week moves a worker from 15 to 25 percent. That's another 10 percent of disposable pay, about $73 a week on my assumption, for a one-cent raise. Nobody would design a raise that way on purpose.
The tiers are brand new. They came in Laws 2024, chapter 114, article 3, section 101. A 2025 law set the effective date: "June 1, 2025, and applies to causes of action commenced on or after that date." Before that, the cap was a flat 25 percent, with only the floor underneath it.
And nobody wrote them into the levy statutes. The execution-levy statute, § 550.136, subd. 3, and the attorney's summary-execution statute, § 551.06, subd. 3, still print "25 percent". The 2025 special session re-enacted both subdivisions, pen in hand, and left the 25 percent right where it was.
What we can do
Adopt the Texas rule for consumer debt. Take wages off the table for an ordinary credit card or consumer judgment, and keep the exceptions Texas keeps: child support and spousal maintenance. Federal law leaves a state free to prohibit garnishment. Three of the states in this table have.
At minimum, pass the Legislature's own first draft, pointed at today's wage. In 2024, H.F. 4100, S.F. 4065 and S.F. 4602 all started at a 10 percent cap with everything under 80 times the minimum wage protected. Committee and conference turned that into today's 25, 15 and 10 above 40 times. The first draft aimed its floor at an old $9.50 wage, so as written it would take $96.00 a week from the $30-an-hour worker. Pointed at today's $11.41, it leaves the $18-an-hour check alone and takes $47.20 from the $30-an-hour check instead of $240. The Legislature already wrote it. It's sitting in a drawer.
Carry the tiers into the levy statutes. Write them into §§ 550.136 and 551.06, so those statutes say in plain words what the garnishment statutes say.
Minnesota doesn't have to become Texas to do better. It just has to get off the federal line.
Sources
Minnesota: Minn. Stat. §§ 571.921, 571.922, 571.75 (subd. 2 worksheet), 550.136, 550.37, 551.06 and 177.24, 2025 editions, at revisor.mn.gov. Session laws: Laws 2020, ch. 86, art. 4, § 20; Laws 2024, ch. 114, art. 3, § 101; Laws 2025, ch. 18, § 21; Laws 2025, 1st Spec. Sess., ch. 4, art. 7, §§ 32–34. Bill text for H.F. 4100, S.F. 4065 and S.F. 4602 as introduced (2024) and S.F. 4097, from the Revisor's bill pages. Minimum wage: Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry, "Minimum wage in Minnesota", $11.41 as of January 1, 2026.
Other states: Tex. Const. art. XVI, § 28 (tcss.legis.texas.gov); 42 Pa.C.S. § 8127 (palegis.us); S.C. Code §§ 37-5-104, 37-3-104, 37-3-106 and 37-1-109(6) (scstatehouse.gov); N.C. Gen. Stat. §§ 1-362 and 1C-1601 (ncleg.gov); N.Y. CPLR 5231(b) (nysenate.gov); 735 ILCS 5/12-803 and 820 ILCS 105/4 (ilga.gov); 10 Del. C. § 4913(a); Nev. Rev. Stat. § 31.295(2); C.R.S. § 13-54-104(2)(a)(I) (2024 printout, leg.colorado.gov); RCW 6.27.150(4); Mo. Rev. Stat. § 525.030(2); N.M. Laws 2023, ch. 104 (S.B. 216), § 2, amending NMSA § 35-12-7(A); N.H. RSA 512:21; Mass. Gen. Laws c. 246, § 28; Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 706.050(a); ORS 18.385; HRS § 652-1(a)(4), (b); Md. Code, Com. Law § 15-601.1(b); Va. Code § 34-29(A). Federal: 15 U.S.C. §§ 1673 and 1677; 20 U.S.C. § 1095a; 29 U.S.C. § 206.
The table is my arithmetic on those texts, with the 40-hour week, the 80 percent disposable-pay assumption and the Minnesota-wage substitution stated under it. The Hawaii figures convert weekly pay to monthly, apply the brackets, and convert back.
What I could not establish. Disposable pay depends on each worker's withholding; the table assumes 80 percent of gross. Most of the other states' formulas use their own minimum wage, and apart from Illinois's I did not run them at it; where a state's own wage is higher than Minnesota's, using it would only lower what that state takes. North Carolina's protection depends on a family-support showing, and I did not survey its special-purpose garnishments for taxes or public creditors. Colorado's rule is from its 2024 statutes and New Mexico's from its 2023 session law. Federal tax levies on wages are outside this comparison. How courts apply the 2024 tiers to judgments from suits filed before June 1, 2025 is a legal question this piece does not answer, and so is whether § 550.37, subd. 13, which exempts "All earnings not subject to garnishment by the provisions of section 571.922", already carries the tiers into levies. Corrections: campaign@madgettformn.com.
Discussion
Comments run on GitHub Discussions, so a free GitHub account is needed to post. Keep it civil and sourced; the house rule is the same as the articles: receipts or it gets removed.